1. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    It *is* informative. It shows how poor the song is and how lazy, repetitive and annoying the guitar part is. Edge's worst instincts are visible here.
    The guitar part in SOD serves the song. This instrumental reveals that.
  2. It's a song that's not worth serving. AI could generate a better song than that and U2 certainly can do better. Edge's paint-by-numbers approach just reinforces the mediocrity instead of trying to rise above it.
  3. I bet when they release the album, the younger generations (Z and Alpha) will embrace it with open arms (given that they've done so many TikTok videos about how amazing U2 are, and wear U2 tshirts without a second thought!) - and us old-timers and doubters will stand there in shock as the scramble for tour tickets ensues.

    I was underwhelmed by the SOD verse, but I'm used to it now.

    Let's enjoy the ride, everybody - we won't necessarily know when it's the last one! 🍻
  4. Originally posted by claytonstache:I bet when they release the album, the younger generations (Z and Alpha) will embrace it with open arms (given that they've done so many TikTok videos about how amazing U2 are, and wear U2 tshirts without a second thought!) - and us old-timers and doubters will stand there in shock as the scramble for tour tickets ensues.

    I was underwhelmed by the SOD verse, but I'm used to it now.

    Let's enjoy the ride, everybody - we won't necessarily know when it's the last one! 🍻


    Based on the EPs, the album will certainly be better. It's just shocking how large the gap can be between U2's highs and lows. Hard to to believe that the same band that wrote Tears of Things is also capable of this shit.
  5. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]


    Based on the EPs, the album will certainly be better. It's just shocking how large the gap can be between U2's highs and lows. Hard to to believe that the same band that wrote Tears of Things is also capable of this shit.
    🀣🀣🀣 I get you

    I’ve got a question for you (and any other fan, really) would you replace any song on The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby for The Tears of Things?
  6. Originally posted by juandicorrea:[..]
    🀣🀣🀣 I get you

    I’ve got a question for you (and any other fan, really) would you replace any song on The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby for The Tears of Things?
    I’m not as big a fan of tears of things as some people so I would say no even though it is still a good song.
    I’d have resurrection song, in a life, scars, Easter parade, one life at a time and song of the future over some of the weaker songs on each album if we were talking quality only rather than what fits stylistically. Everything else on the EP’s not quite.
  7. Originally posted by juandicorrea:[..]
    🀣🀣🀣 I get you

    I’ve got a question for you (and any other fan, really) would you replace any song on The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby for The Tears of Things?
    TOT doesn't fit on both JT and AB, so no. But i find TOT way better than TTYW and IGC for example. Or TTYAATW
  8. Originally posted by juandicorrea:I’ve got a question for you (and any other fan, really) would you replace any song on The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby for The Tears of Things?
    If you swapped out So Cruel for Tears of Things, Achtung Baby would be exponentially better.
  9. Fascinating. I think So Cruel is incredibly underrated and is among my favorite tracks on AB, and ToT is a song I don't get the love for at all. Of the 13 tracks this year, I would only rate it above Wildpeace, American Obituary, and (maybe) Street of Dreams...
  10. Hard disagree with this! So Cruel is a lyrical masterpiece imo. TOT can’t compare. TOT is fine for recent career U2 but does not measure up to their best work.
  11. Originally posted by juandicorrea:[..]
    🀣🀣🀣 I get you

    I’ve got a question for you (and any other fan, really) would you replace any song on The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby for The Tears of Things?
    "The Tears of Things" isn't one of my favourites on the EP. Stuff in there I like much better. But both The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby are just fine as they are. Wouldn't want to see anything replaced.
  12. Originally posted by bstie1198:[..]
    Fascinating. I think So Cruel is incredibly underrated and is among my favorite tracks on AB, and ToT is a song I don't get the love for at all. Of the 13 tracks this year, I would only rate it above Wildpeace, American Obituary, and (maybe) Street of Dreams...
    TOT will reveal itself live. Watch.