1. Great question! Bono's political rants are hated by some, embraced by others. Personally, I wish Larry replaced 30% or so of the looped/sampled percussion. Pop is my 3rd favorite album, and I don't mind the vocal effects on Wake Up Dead Man. The top 40 in 1997 wasn't overrun with any particular vocal effect. Love Is All, Fireflies, and Coexist are not creative use of vocal effects, but simply remind me of 400 billion other artists following a trend with a specific need to sound like everyone else. I may be in the minority, but I want my legends to start trends, but not to follow them. I am forever in debt to them for all the joy they have brought me. But just as I have been critical of Prince, Aerosmith, and my other favorite artists, I try to be honest. Hell, they overdid the drum machine in Treason, but I still love, love, love it. Your Song Saved is run of the mill cookie cutter 2000s U2...but as cringe worthy as parts of it are, it touches my soul..rant over.
  2. I’ve made up a playlist lately that goes like this

    Fireflies
    Tears of things
    Song of the future
    One life at a time
    In a life
    Scars
    Resurrection song
    Easter parade

    If that had been the new u2 album I would have ranked it very highly, probably contending with All that you can’t leave behind and Zooropa for 3rd best. Tracks 2-5 on Easter Lily is the best sequence of 4 songs on a u2 record since the opening 5 on All that you can’t leave behind then you’d need to go back to Achtung Baby for another better 4 or more in a row.
  3. Originally posted by tuf392664:I’ve made up a playlist lately that goes like this

    Fireflies
    Tears of things
    Song of the future
    One life at a time
    In a life
    Scars
    Resurrection song
    Easter parade

    If that had been the new u2 album I would have ranked it very highly, probably contending with All that you can’t leave behind and Zooropa for 3rd best. Tracks 2-5 on Easter Lily is the best sequence of 4 songs on a u2 record since the opening 5 on All that you can’t leave behind then you’d need to go back to Achtung Baby for another better 4 or more in a row.
    Just putting this on for a listen now ๐Ÿ™‚
  4. Tracks 2-5 on Easter Lily is the best sequence of 4 songs on a u2 record since the opening 5 on All that you can’t leave behind then you’d need to go back to Achtung Baby for another better 4 or more in a row.


    I agree with this, though I would say tracks 1-6 are the best sequence of songs since ATYCLB side A. Since I'm very fond of Pop and Zooropa, I don't think I'd agree with needing to go back to AB. But yes, I think this is their strongest string of songs since ATYCLB. (Which may say something about the relative weakness of their output over the last 20 years).
  5. Originally posted by dstankie:[..]


    I agree with this, though I would say tracks 1-6 are the best sequence of songs since ATYCLB side A. Since I'm very fond of Pop and Zooropa, I don't think I'd agree with needing to go back to AB. But yes, I think this is their strongest string of songs since ATYCLB. (Which may say something about the relative weakness of their output over the last 20 years).
    It’s just great it’s a release that a good chunk of the fanbase have been able to get behind. Feels like a while since the band have had so many fans on side with a collection of new material.
  6. I would leave Easter Lily as it is. It's a great collection of songs indeed. And it adds up to 10 songs.

    Fireflies
    Tears of things
    Song of the future
    One life at a time
    Song for Hal
    In a life
    Scars
    Resurrection song
    Easter parade
    Coexist
  7. Originally posted by tuf392664:I’ve made up a playlist lately that goes like this

    Fireflies
    Tears of things
    Song of the future
    One life at a time
    In a life
    Scars
    Resurrection song
    Easter parade

    If that had been the new u2 album I would have ranked it very highly, probably contending with All that you can’t leave behind and Zooropa for 3rd best. Tracks 2-5 on Easter Lily is the best sequence of 4 songs on a u2 record since the opening 5 on All that you can’t leave behind then you’d need to go back to Achtung Baby for another better 4 or more in a row.
    Just to know, not to critisise: if you rank atyclb 3rd (asuming you put AB and JT 1 and 2), where did you rank Pop, TUF and Boy which in my opinion are way better than atyclb. And Zooropa of course, but you rank Zooropa also 3rd ๐Ÿ‘
  8. Originally posted by Zwervervriend:[..]
    Just to know, not to critisise: if you rank atyclb 3rd (asuming you put AB and JT 1 and 2), where did you rank Pop, TUF and Boy which in my opinion are way better than atyclb. And Zooropa of course, but you rank Zooropa also 3rd ๐Ÿ‘
    Achtung baby
    Joshua tree
    All that you can’t leave behind
    Zooropa
    Pop/The Unforgettable fire/Easter Lily
    War
    Boy
    How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb
    Songs Of Innocence
    No Line On The Horizon
    Days of Ash
    October
    Songs of experience
    Rattle and hum

    There’s my ranking there, did it a few days ago on the rank the albums thread. Very close between ATYCLB and Zooropa. If Bono was on vocals for the wanderer I think Zooropa might have just edged it.
  9. Originally posted by tuf392664:[..]
    Achtung baby
    Joshua tree
    All that you can’t leave behind
    Zooropa
    Pop/The Unforgettable fire/Easter Lily
    War
    Boy
    How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb
    Songs Of Innocence
    No Line On The Horizon
    Days of Ash
    October
    Songs of experience
    Rattle and hum

    There’s my ranking there, did it a few days ago on the rank the albums thread. Very close between ATYCLB and Zooropa. If Bono was on vocals for the wanderer I think Zooropa might have just edged it.
    ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘
  10. Originally posted by tuf392664:[..]
    Achtung baby
    Joshua tree
    All that you can’t leave behind
    Zooropa
    Pop/The Unforgettable fire/Easter Lily
    War
    Boy
    How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb
    Songs Of Innocence
    No Line On The Horizon
    Days of Ash
    October
    Songs of experience
    Rattle and hum

    There’s my ranking there, did it a few days ago on the rank the albums thread. Very close between ATYCLB and Zooropa. If Bono was on vocals for the wanderer I think Zooropa might have just edged it.
    Ha. I find it hilarious that many fans are wiping away the existence of what many, and myself consider their worst album. You don't even listen it hahaha. Now I have a different somewhat longer name for it:


    Songs Of Surrendering To The Old Artist Trend Of Re-recording Old Songs.
  11. Am I the only one (occasionally) listening to SOS?