1. Originally posted by deanallison:How would you put they ratings into terms roughly? As in what score does a song need to be before you would say you like it? Poor, Average, good, great.

    As an example I’d say a 1 is very poor I don’t like it, a 6 would be fine I wouldn’t tend to listen to the song in isolation but I can somewhat enjoy it when it comes on an album or played live, a 10 would be perfect I love the song.
    Couple things in consideration:
    Studio only - There are a bunch of tracks that I prefer live over studio - Until the End of World, Love and Peace, Silver & Gold, etc.

    1-3 - Subpar U2 song, wouldn't vouch as a good song to a non-U2 fan
    3-6 - Decent U2 song
    7-8.5 - Good U2 song, usually a really nice album track
    8.5-10 - Great U2 song, love it, and would recommend it to somebody when showing off a great U2 track.
  2. Originally posted by hoserama:[..]
    Couple things in consideration:
    Studio only - There are a bunch of tracks that I prefer live over studio - Until the End of World, Love and Peace, Silver & Gold, etc.

    1-3 - Subpar U2 song, wouldn't vouch as a good song to a non-U2 fan
    3-6 - Decent U2 song
    7-8.5 - Good U2 song, usually a really nice album track
    8.5-10 - Great U2 song, love it, and would recommend it to somebody when showing off a great U2 track.
    How would you rate "When Love Comes To Town?"
  3. Good catch, not sure how I missed that one.

    Probably 6.5. I really liked hearing Lovetown live in 2015.
  4. Boy: 8,5/10
    1. I Will Follow: 10/10
    2. Twilight: 7,5/10
    3. An Cat Dubh: 8/10
    4. Into The Heart: 6,5/10
    5. Out Of Control: 8,5/10
    6. Stories For Boys: 7/10
    7. The Ocean: 9/10
    8. A Day Without Me: 7,5/10
    9. Another Time, Another Place: 9,5/10
    10. The Electric Co.: 10/10
    11. Shadows And Tall Trees: 9,5/10
    October: 7/10
    1. Gloria: 9,5/10
    2. I Fall Down: 7/10
    3. I Threw A Brick Through A Window: 8/10
    4. Rejoice: 7,5/10
    5. Fire: 7,5/10
    6. Tomorrow: 6,5/10
    7. October: 9/10
    8. With A Shout (Jerusalem): 6,5/10
    9. Stranger In A Stranger Land: 6/10
    10. Scarlet: 8/10
    11. Is That All?: 7/10
    War: 8/10
    1. Sunday Bloody Sunday: 10/10
    2. Seconds: 9/10
    3. New Year’s Day: 10/10
    4. Like A Song: 8,5/10
    5. Drowning Man: 7,5/10
    6. The Refugee: 6,5/10
    7. Two Hearts Beat As One: 10/10
    8. Red Light: 7/10
    9. Surrender: 9/10
    10. “40”: 9,5/10
    The Unforgettable Fire: 9/10
    1. A Sort Of Homecoming: 10/10
    2. Pride (In The Name Love): 10/10
    3. Wire: 7,5/10
    4. The Unforgettable Fire: 9,5/10
    5. Promenade: 10/10
    6. 4th Of July: 7,5/10
    7. Bad: 10/10
    8. Indian Summer Sky: 7/10
    9. Elvis Presley And America: 6,5/10
    10. MLK: 9,5/10
    The Joshua Tree: 10/10
    1. Where The Streets Have No Name: 10/10
    2. I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For: 10/10
    3. With Or Without You: 10/10
    4. Bullet The Blue Sky: 9,5/10
    5. Running To Stand Still: 10/10
    6. Red Hill Mining Town: 8/10
    7. In God’s Country: 10/10
    8. Trip Through Your Wires: 9/10
    9. One Tree Hill: 10/10
    10. Exit: 9,5/10
    11. Mothers Of The Disappeared: 10/10
    Rattle And Hum: 9/10
    1. Helter Skelter: 9/10
    2. Van Diemend’s Land: 8,5/10
    3. Desire: 10/10
    4. Hawkmoon 269: 8/10
    5. All Along The Watchtower: 10/10
    6. Silver And Gold: 10/10
    7. Angel Of Harlem: 9/10
    8. Love Rescue Me: 10/10
    9. When Love Comes To Town: 7/10
    10. Heartland: 10/10
    11. God, Pt. II: 9,5/10
    12. All I Want Is You: 10/10
    Achtung Baby: 10/10
    1. Zoo Station: 9,5/10
    2. Even Better Than The Real Thing: 10/10
    3. One: 10/10
    4. Until The End Of The World: 9,5/10
    5. Who’s Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses: 10/10
    6. So Cruel: 8,5/10
    7. The Fly: 10/10
    8. Mysterious Ways: 10/10
    9. Tryin’ To Throw Your Arms Around The World: 9/10
    10. Ultra Violet (Light My Way): 10/10
    11. Acrobat: 10/10
    12. Love Is Blindness: 10/10
    Zooropa: 7,5/10
    1. Zooropa: 9,5/10
    2. Babyface: 9/10
    3. Numb: 7/10
    4. Lemon: 8/10
    5. Stay (Faraway, So Close!): 10/10
    6. Daddy’s Gonna Pay For Your Crashed Car: 6,5/10
    7. Some Days Are Better Than Others: 5/10
    8. The First Time: 10/10
    9. Dirty Day: 10/10
    10. The Wanderer: 7,5/10
    Pop: 7/10
    1. Discotheque: 10/10
    2. Do You Feel Loved?: 9/10
    3. Mofo: 8,5/10
    4. If God Will Send His Angels: 6,5/10
    5. Staring At The Sun: 8,5/10
    6. Last Night On Heart: 7/10
    7. Gone: 9/10
    8. Miami: 1/10
    9. The Playboy Mansion: 1/10
    10. If You Wear That Velvet Dress: 10/10
    11. Please: 9,5/10
    12. Wake Up Dead Man: 9/10
    All That You Can’t Leave Behind: 8/10
    1. Beautiful Day: 9,5/10
    2. Stuck In A Moment: 9/10
    3. Elevation: 10/10
    4. Walk On: 10/10
    5. Kite: 9/10
    6. In A Little While: 8/10
    7. Wild Honey: 6/10
    8. Peace On Heart: 6,5/10
    9. When I Look At The Heart: 7/10
    10. New York: 9,5/10
    11. Grace: 3/10
    12. The Ground Beneath Her Feet: 9/10
    i got tired
  5. Boy
    I will follow 9
    Twilight 7
    An Cat Dubh 8
    Into The Heart 8
    Out Of control 7
    Stories for boys 5
    The Ocean 5
    A Day Without Me 5
    Another Time, Another Place 6
    The Electric Co. 7
    Shadows And Tall Trees 4

    Average - 64.55

    October
    Gloria 8
    I fall Down 5
    I Threw A Brick Through A Window 5
    Rejoice 5
    Fire 4
    Tomorrow 7
    October 7
    With A Shout 6
    Stranger In A Strange Land 3
    Scarlet 6
    Is That All 2

    Average - 52.73

    War
    Sunday Bloody Sunday 9
    Seconds 6
    New Years Day 10
    Like A Song 7
    Drowning Man 9
    The Refugee 3
    Two Hearts Beat As One 5
    Red Light 2
    Surrender 6
    40 8

    Average - 65.00

    The Unforgettable Fire
    A Sort Of Homecoming 8
    Pride (In The Name Of Love) 8
    Wire 8
    The Unforgettable Fire 9
    Promenade 7
    4th Of July 5
    Bad 10
    Indian Summer Sky 5
    Elvis Presley And America 3
    MLK 6

    Average - 69.00

    The Joshua Tree
    Where the streets have no name 10
    I still haven’t found what I’m looking for 8
    With or without you 10
    Bullet the blue sky 9
    Running to stand still 8
    Red hill mining town 7
    In gods country 7
    Trip through your wires 6
    One tree hill 8
    Exit 8
    Mothers of the disappeared 6

    Average - 79.09

    Rattle And Hum
    Van Diemens Land 6
    Desire 5
    Hawkmoon 269 6
    Silver And Gold 5
    Angel of Harlem 7
    Love Rescue Me 5
    When Love Comes To Town 4
    Heartland 8
    God Part II 5
    All I Want Is You 8

    Average - 59.00

    Achtung Baby
    Zoo station 10
    Even better than the real thing 9
    One 10
    Until the end of the world 9
    Who’s gonna ride your wild horses 8
    So cruel 6
    The fly 9
    Mysterious ways 8
    Tryin to throw your arms around the world 6
    Ultraviolet 10
    Acrobat 8
    Love is blindness 9

    Average - 85.00

    Zooropa
    Zooropa 9
    Babyface 6
    Numb 7
    Lemon 7
    Stay (Faraway So close!) 10
    Daddy’s gonna pay for your crashed car 7
    Some days are better than others 6
    The first time 7
    Dirty day 8
    The wanderer 3

    Average - 70.00

    Pop
    Discotheque 6
    Do You Feel Loved 6
    Mofo 6
    If God Will Send His Angels 7
    Staring At The Sun 8
    Last Night On Earth 7
    Gone 9
    Miami 3
    Playboy Mansion 4
    If You Wear That Velvet dress 8
    Please 7
    Wake up dead man 7

    Average - 65.00

    All That You Can’t Leave Behind
    Beautiful day 9
    Stuck in a moment 9
    Elevation 8
    Walk on 9
    Kite 8
    In a little while 6
    Wild honey 5
    Peace on Earth 5
    When I look at the world 7
    New York 7
    Grace 5
    Ground beneath her feet 8

    Average - 71.67

    How to dismantle an atomic bomb
    Vertigo 8
    Miracle drug 7
    Sometimes you can’t make it on your own 8
    Love and peace or else 6
    City of blinding lights 9
    All because of you 5
    A man and a woman 5
    Crumbs from your table 6
    One step closer 5
    Original of the species 7
    Yahweh 7
    Fast cars 4

    Average - 64.17

    No Line On The Horizon
    No Line On The Horizon 6
    Magnificent 7
    Moment of surrender 7
    Unknown caller 6
    I’ll go crazy if I don’t go crazy tonight 5
    Get on your boots 5
    Stand up comedy 5
    Fez-Being Born 6
    White as snow 7
    Breathe 8
    Cedars of Lebanon 5

    Average - 60.91

    Songs Of Innocence
    The miracle (of Joey ramone) 6
    Every breaking wave 8
    California (there is no end to love) 8
    Song for someone 7
    Iris (hold me close). 7
    Volcano 5
    Raised by wolves 6
    Cedarwood road 7
    Sleep like a baby tonight 4
    This is where you can reach me now 5
    The troubles 6

    Average - 62.73

    Songs of experience
    Love is all we have left 5
    Lights of home 8
    You’re the best thing about me 5
    Get out of your own way 5
    American soul 4
    Summer of love 7
    Red flag day 5
    The showman 3
    The little things that give you away 7
    Landlady 6
    The blackout 7
    Love is bigger than anything in its way 7
    13 (there is a light) 5

    Average - 56.92

    Days of ash
    American Obituary 5
    Tears of things 6
    Song of the future 8
    Wildpeace 4
    One life at a time 8
    Yours eternally 5

    Average - 60.00

    Easter Lily
    Song For Hal 5
    In a Life 8
    Scars 8
    Resurrection song 8
    Easter parade 8
    Coexist 5

    Average - 70.00

    Ranking
    1. Achtung Baby (85.00)
    2. The Joshua Tree (79.09)
    3. All That You Can’t Leave Behind (71.67)
    4/5. Zooropa/Easter Lily (70.00)
    6. The unforgettable fire (69.00)
    7/8. Pop/War (65.00)
    9. Boy (64.55)
    10. How to dismantle an atomic bomb (64.17)
    11. Songs of Innocence (62.73)
    12. No Line On The Horizon (60.91)
    13. Days Of Ash (60.00)
    14. Rattle and hum (59.00)
    15. Songs of experience (56.92)
    16. October (52.73)
  6. I remember 15-20 years ago there where a Program where you rated all U2 album by each song and then it created statics by it so you could see which one had the best scores by the songs.
    Anyone here who is a progeammer who could create that?
  7. boy
    i will follow 8
    twilight 7
    an cat dubh/into the heart 10
    out of control 8
    stories for boys 6
    the ocean 5
    a day without me 6
    another time, another place 5
    the electric co. 10
    shadows and tall trees 8
    average: 7.3

    october
    gloria 9
    i fall down 7
    i threw a brick through a window 7
    rejoice 4
    fire 5
    tomorrow 4
    october 7
    with a shout 3
    stranger in a strange land 3
    scarlet 7
    is that all? 2
    average: 5.3

    war
    sunday bloody sunday 10
    seconds 8
    new year's day 10
    like a song... 7
    drowning man 7
    the refugee 9
    two hearts beat as one 7
    red light 8
    surrender 9
    "40" 7
    average: 8.2

    the unforgettable fire
    a sort of homecoming 10
    pride (in the name of love) 10
    wire 8
    the unforgettable fire 10
    promenade 7
    4th of july 4
    bad 10
    indian summer sky 7
    elvis presley and america 6
    mlk 6
    average: 7.8

    the joshua tree
    where the streets have no name 10
    i still haven't found what i'm looking for 10
    with or without you 10
    bullet the blue sky 10
    running to stand still 8
    red hill mining town 10
    in god's country 8
    trip through your wires 10
    one tree hill 10
    exit 7
    mothers of the disappeared 5
    average: 8.9

    rattle and hum
    van diemen's land 8
    desire 10
    hawkmoon 269 9
    silver and gold (live) 7
    angel of harlem 10
    love rescue me 7
    when love comes to town 8
    heartland 9
    god part II 9
    all i want is you 10
    average: 8.7

    achtung baby
    zoo station 8
    even better than the real thing 8
    one 10
    until the end of the world 10
    who's gonna ride your wild horses 8
    so cruel 7
    the fly 10
    mysterious ways 10
    tryin' to throw your arms around the world 8
    ultra violet (light my way) 9
    acrobat 9
    love is blindness 8
    average: 8.7

    zooropa
    zooropa 10
    babyface 8
    numb 8
    lemon 7
    stay (faraway, so close!) 10
    daddy's gonna pay for your crashed car 9
    some days are better than others 9
    the first time 6
    dirty day 10
    the wanderer 7
    average: 8.4

    pop
    discothèque 8
    do you feel loved 10
    mofo 8
    if god will send his angels 7
    staring at the sun 10
    last night on earth 9
    gone 8
    miami 9
    the playboy mansion 9
    if you wear that velvet dress 4
    please 6
    wake up dead man 6
    average: 7.8

    all that you can't leave behind
    beautiful day 10
    stuck in a moment you can't get out of 8
    elevation 9
    walk on 7
    kite 8
    in a little while 8
    wild honey 6
    peace on earth 5
    when i look at the world 6
    new york 10
    grace 6
    average: 7.5

    how to dismantle an atomic bomb
    vertigo 10
    miracle drug 9
    sometimes you can't make it on your own 10
    love and peace or else 8
    city of blinding lights 10
    all because of you 8
    a man and a woman 7
    crumbs from your table 7
    one step closer 6
    original of the species 8
    yahweh 8
    average: 8.3

    no line on the horizon
    no line on the horizon 6
    magnificent 8
    moment of surrender 9
    unknown caller 7
    i'll go crazy if i don't go crazy tonight 10
    get on yout boots 8
    stand up comedy 9
    fez - being born 7
    white as snow 5
    breathe 7
    cedars of lebanon 2
    average: 7.1

    songs of innocence
    the miracle (of joey ramone) 7
    every breaking wave 10
    california (there is no end to love) 8
    song for someone 9
    iris (hold me close) 7
    volcano 8
    raised by wolves 8
    cedarwood road 6
    sleep like a baby tonight 9
    this is where you can reach me now 8
    the troubles 10
    average: 8.2

    songs of experience
    love is all we have left 7
    lights of home 10
    you're the best thing about me 9
    get out of your own way 7
    american soul 8
    summer of love 6
    red flag day 8
    the showman (little more better) 8
    the little things that give you away 8
    landlady 8
    the blackout 8
    love is bigger than anything in its way 5
    13 (there is a light) 4
    average: 7.4

    days of ash
    american obituary 7
    the tear of things 5
    song of the future 9
    wildpeace 5
    one life at a time 10
    yours eternally 5
    average: 6.8

    easter lily
    song for hal 5
    in a life 5
    scars 5
    resurrection song 7
    easter parade 8
    coexist (i will bless the lord at all time¿) 7
    average: 6.2
  8. I feel like with the 2 EP’s being a part of the Carnaval de luz deluxe set and the whole thing being connected we can take the EP’s as one album. Here’s how I’m feeling about it at the moment.

    Days of Ash/Easter Lily

    American Obituary 7
    Tears Of Things 7
    Song Of The Future 7
    Wildpeace 4
    One life at a time 8
    Yours eternally 6
    Song for Hal 6
    In A Life 8
    Scars 8
    Resurrection Song 9
    Easter Parade 8
    Coexist 5

    Average - 69.17

    Ranking as my 5th best u2 album which is a great effort at this point in their career. American obituary has really grown on me again.
  9. Well aware this is very early to do be doing ratings but it’s not like I can’t change it in the future. I feel like I’ve been careful with my ratings here too, trying not to be overly generous.

    Carnaval De Luz

    Go 7
    La Reina 8
    Street Of Dreams 5
    Mirror Maker (Rosalía) 7
    Superficiality 7
    If the world is at war we better not be 5
    Silencio 7
    The greatest show on earth 9
    Glorify 5
    Midnight sunshine 7
    Can’t stop us now 9
    Torn 5

    Average - 67.5

    Ranking in 7th place amongst all of u2’s albums.