1. Originally posted by Sev00:The crescendo singing in the outro is so weirdly out of place for a U2 song and I absolutely love it. Same for the "Hey ! Jesus of Rio !" Lines and how they're sung.

    But what I think makes this song so good is the broken up structure, the verses blending with choruses and vice versa, one bleeding over the other, the three different sections instead of just verses and choruses

    They found a way to make four 67 year old guys rocking out absolutely cool instead of uncool, by having fun with it.


    None of them are 67 yet! Don't age them any faster than they already are lol
  2. I don't know if I'm overhyping it, but it might be the most exciting single since Vertigo?
  3. It's the best since Vertigo I think, live it will be great!
    Hope they can extend the outro! It's a rocker!
  4. I have some reservations about it. At this point, it’s just some hype. Only time will tell if it stacks up with the best or not. A longer outro, for sure, might help. But, I can’t help but feel that they botched up a great potential song. I’m looking forward to the next single. It might actually end up being the real comeback single.
  5. The outro AND the intro can and deserve to be extended. Btw, not sure if anyone felt it thought of this, but the chorus could have one more "silencio" and one more "where did our love go?" before "jesus of rio", like so:

    "Silencio, Silencio
    Silencio, Silencio
    Where did our love go?
    Silencio
    Where did our love go?
    Jesus of Rio"

    IDK, it plays smoothly in my mind, feels like that groove could have those extra seconds, and I really like the melody of "where did our love go?".
  6. Wouldn’t want Silencio being any longer than it is. That’s the point of the song 2 and a half minutes and done, no messing about. Less is more sometimes.
  7. I love Silencio so much! There is a real mature youthful energy there. I have a feeling the rest of the album and tour production will help us understand the deeper layers of these songs.

    Also, the production seems well done. Was listening yesterday on my dad’s Marantz/Thiel amplifier/speaker combination. So much clarity, tightness and warmth there. Never before have I been able to detect much interest in U2’s music or their (over…)production in my dad, but he was really enjoying and impressed with Silencio.
  8. Believe it or not but I've only just listened to Silencio because I wanted to first listen to it with my partner - and we were both pleasantly surprised

    Exciting and interesting with plenty of moving parts - no, not my partner but Silencio

    Love the attitude and it didn't fell like Dad's playing at being young at all - I can't understand all the hate 👎

    SOD to me is throwaway but not overly unpleasant whereas Silencio is on another level 😎

    Exciting times ahead...