1. This was an "official sleeve" that would have been... (source at 08:34
    Music show: Girls in Hawaii, U2 and Miguel youtube.com/watch?v=F7sKZlLS1EM)
  2. Has anyone else re-appraised this release in light of all the music we have been given in 2026?

    I am thinking of it differently.
  3. Originally posted by miryclay:Has anyone else re-appraised this release in light of all the music we have been given in 2026?

    I am thinking of it differently.
    Absolutely! I was just thinking about posting some thoughts on Songs of Surrender. I was listening to this album all day today (again). 40 songs version obviously. I’m so happy that they released SoS and I appreciate it now more than ever. Some of the arrangements are actually the ones that I prefer over the originals. Pride is the best example as the old version is so… tiresome and boring after thousands of listens, but this new one is awesome and it shows how great of a song Pride really is. I like most of the new arrangements on SoS. Ones that are not as great are those too close to the originals (Stuck for example).

    When I make a list of best U2 albums, this is usually the last one. Sometimes SoE goes last. But truth is that it just shouldn’t be on the list at all as it’s not a straightforward studio album that can be compared with other albums. For many months it also happened to be one of the U2 albums that I listened to most often. And I’m very happy that they chose to record and release it. It is here to stay.

    Also, you need to listen to this album on a good stereo and then it sounds amazing, open and completely different. When I try listening on my HomePod mini it sounds so flat that I only want to turn it off. Perhaps that’s why many people don’t like it still.

    I think that true purpose of this album is that it allowed them to close one chapter and start another, which we can only see now. Without SOS there might be no new music from the band.
  4. Originally posted by miryclay:Has anyone else re-appraised this release in light of all the music we have been given in 2026?

    I am thinking of it differently.
    Being honest the new material has allowed me to forget about SOS almost entirely which I’m happy about. The initial release really disappointed me. However, when I went through a phase of chasing down alternative versions of songs I gave more of it a chance. From the 40 songs at that point I maybe could have picked out an albums worth. At this point I’ve maybe got a handful left that I think are good. Some of the songs were close and then just failed on certain aspects. I don’t like Bono’s vocals on most of it whether that be the mix or the style of singing itself. I think his voice and the mixes in the 2026 songs have been much better.
  5. Originally posted by Bonu:[..]
    Absolutely! I was just thinking about posting some thoughts on Songs of Surrender. I was listening to this album all day today (again). 40 songs version obviously. I’m so happy that they released SoS and I appreciate it now more than ever. Some of the arrangements are actually the ones that I prefer over the originals. Pride is the best example as the old version is so… tiresome and boring after thousands of listens, but this new one is awesome and it shows how great of a song Pride really is. I like most of the new arrangements on SoS. Ones that are not as great are those too close to the originals (Stuck for example).

    Summing up, when I make a list of best U2 albums, this is always the last one. Sometimes SoE goes last. But truth is that it just shouldn’t be on the list at all as it’s not a straightforward studio album that can be compared with other albums. For many months it also happened to be one of the U2 albums that I listened to most often. And I’m very happy that they chose to record and release it. It is here to stay.

    Also, you need to listen to this album on a good stereo and then it sounds amazing, open and completely different. When I try listening on my HomePod mini it sounds so flat that I only want to turn it off. Perhaps that’s why many people don’t like it still.

    I think that true purpose of this album is that it allowed them to close one chapter and start another, which we can only see now. Without SOS there might be no new music from the band.
    Yes you’re right. Thanks for bringing it up!

    Without the introspective period and “surrender” that Bono and the band did (facing the past psychologically, emotionally, and musically speaking) to be “liberated” from it in order to walk “free” into the future, we wouldn’t have the high quality songs we’ve heard in 2026….

    Freedom as an internal feeling, and true Joy as well, are attainable after a long process of self-reflection and facing past traumas and dealing and closing chapters of our childhoods/bonds with parents, in order to heal and be “free”. To be “free” can mean to truly “be yourself” and be able to sing, dream, and feel joy and the “carnival and transcendent elements” of life. Doing what you love and what you’ve once dreamed of when being a kid.

    That’s why Street of Dreams and all this Freedom, Joy, and post-surrender themes they are exploring in Carnaval de Luz and the EPs.

    Or at least, that’s my interpretation 🙂
  6. SOI, SOE and SOS was indeed a “deconstruction” of their selves and music in order to dream it all up again.

    And I think time will prove that that 2014-2023 era of the band is actually what gives U2 an edge over other bands. Because they went through the process and came out of it renewed and able to produce their strongest music in decades (2026).

    Few other artists have sucessfully done this before, as far as I am concerned
  7. SOS is a kind of liberation on many levels. At the very least it allowed them to be a band that isn’t ashamed to record new music that sounds unabashedly like U2 again. We can only hear the results of the whole process now and look at SOS in a different light.