1. Originally posted by tuf392664:Seeing that there’s a few cleaned up versions gets me thinking about a question I’ve had in my head since the song was released. Are the explicit lyrics necessary? I’m far from someone who’s afraid of the odd swear word but in music I feel like it has to add something or be fitting to the song. I think it maybe stands out too much and not really in a way that benefits the song. The 2nd in particular ‘there’s a diet saying spit it fucking out’ I don’t think are good lyrics at all. Would love for Bono to change that live.
    I think the F bombs work in a world with news reels stuffed full of actual bombs. We are all so desensitised to a lot of horrible and traumatic events that a bit of swearing almost goes unnoticed.
  2. Maybe I’ll come round to it. I wasn’t sure about all the lyrics in the verses at first then started enjoying them just with they exceptions. It could just be the diet thing, just feels a weird reference in the song.

    Acrobat for example it works and wake up dead man as well.

    I like ‘save you’ by pearl jam as well, go and google they lyrics lol.

    Anyway doesn’t stop me enjoying the song as a whole.
  3. I just learned this song is about Brasil

    Just in time for elections, and the terrible interference by the U.S happening right now and people are literally in Silencio…

    Come on Brasil! Stand Up!! 🇧🇷❤️
  4. Besides the Jesus of Rio line, i dont think it's about Brasil.

    It could work for many instances: Gaza, ICE, Cornell...
  5. It’s about silence and indifference towards the wars, atrocities, and injustices prevalent today. They all start with lies though (we all know their father mentioned in the song). And what too many people do when they hear a lie? They remain silent. The bigger the lie the more deafening is the silence. So where exactly did the love go? We all felt it so intensely in U2 concerts over the years and where is it now? This is the question I hear in this song.

    Silencio could be about almost anywhere really. Places in the world that this song does not speak about are the happy ones.
  6. Of course the political aspect of the song is important, but the silence in the lyrics has a broader meaning. It’s also juxtaposed with loudness of rock and roll, but also a loud, celebratory, ecstatic life (in the spirit of the carnival) - the line about the diet being of the devil speaks to that. If anything the song is about how what we often associate with God and piety - silence, self-deprivation, restraint - can serve evil ends or be harmful when seen in a certain context.
  7. What hurts me is calling wars, atrocities and injustices just politics and so staying away from the dirty subject. This is also the silence that this song is about. First and foremost those are human tragedies not politics and I don’t consider this song political. It’s just talking about reality of human condition in 2026. Of course Bono is rarely direct in his lyrics and all those other meanings to the song are also there in the background to make it more of a poetry and less of a journalism but prevailing theme of the song for me is clear.
  8. I didn't listen to the song the last week, is that bad?
  9. Originally posted by Bonu:What hurts me is calling wars, atrocities and injustices just politics and so staying away from the dirty topic. This is also the silence that this song is about. First and foremost those are human tragedies not politics and I don’t consider this song political. It’s just talking about reality of human condition in 2026. But of course Bono is rarely direct in his lyrics and all those other meanings to the song are also there in the background to make it more of a poetry and less of a journalism.
    There’s nothing dirty about calling it politics, wars and injustice are inherently political. Politics affect human lives directly, I don’t really see any contradiction here. In a way “silence is political” in that choosing not to speak out is a political choice is one of the song’s messages.
  10. Originally posted by Hansav:[..]
    There’s nothing dirty about calling it politics, wars and injustice are inherently political. Politics affect human lives directly, I don’t really see any contradiction here. In a way “silence is political” in that choosing not to speak out is a political choice is one of the song’s messages.
    I agree with that. Many people though see all politics as dirty and so calling wars politics give them a great excuse to remain silent and safely not take sides between aggressors and the victims.
  11. Same … after the initial excitement for the track it’s dawned on me this is another throw away ordinary single. Pains me to say that.