1. Is there a radio edit of this?
  2. Silencio is "The Fly" of Carnival de Luz. Greatest Show on Earth is the "One" of Carnaval de Luz.

    Yes, secretly hoping this is their best album since Achtung Baby.
  3. If this is the best since 'Bomb' i'm satisfied
  4. It still rocks.
  5. I must say I'm not listening to it anymore as much as I play GSOE and Easter Lily on repeat

    But, when GSOE ends and Silencio comes up, I don't skip it. The same thing with Street of Dreams. They are so different that having them in the same album kind of makes each song sound "refreshing".

    I think Silencio will be fun live after Out of Control or I Will Follow
  6. Chut is the best moment
  7. I still think this is a fun little rocker that will definitely go over well live. Far from an essential piece of the U2 catalog, but worth an occasional listen and deserves a spot on this tour imo.

    While short, I absolutely think the break should eliminate either the Campo de Cristo or the shhhh…having both feels unnecessary in the song. I’d prefer just the “shhhh”. Minor quibble.


  8. That silent pause relates back to the theme of the song.

    But I agree that Bono's words interfere -- during the Mount Temple performance there was barely any silence because of his Italian-accented “Campo de Cristo de silencio, shh” before the music starts back up.
  9. Worst part of any U2 song in a long while indeed.
    It would have been great if he just went for the shushing