Originally posted by tuf392664:[..]
I have no complaints with them releasing the 2 ep’s and the album the way they have. Actually I think it’s the best thing because I agree they probably wouldn’t have picked out the best songs to make 1 great album.
But my point stands that the quality of material is far more important than any theme or style running through an album. If you get quality and theme right however you end up with an all time great ( see Achtung baby) but I think at this stage of the bands career an Achtung Baby is impossible so just focus on quality.
In terms of how I listen to the material I’m sure I will listen to them that way on a few occasions but eventually weaker tracks will be deleted. In fact I’ve already deleted street of dreams.
Everyone will make their own playlists these days. That’s for the listeners, like you already did. They shouldn’t try to make a playlist that will satisfy everyone cause it won’t. Only thing they actually can do is trying to create an album that will hold up as a whole artistically. That’s exactly what they did but how people will listen to the stuff they released this year is outside their control. This is how I see it. And it’s great that they chose to release 27 new songs this year, not just 10 or 12. It’s enough choice for everyone to create any playlist they want.
Edit: It says, "Join U2 live for an exclusive preview of Carnaval de Luz," - I'd personally interpret that as the band being present!