1. Perhaps instead of slagging Bono for writing a song celebrating a woman like Rosalía, we should be applauding him.

    In a world where we are increasingly confronted with stories of powerful men abusing their positions and women, there is something refreshing about a man expressing admiration for a woman through his art.

    We have seen the likes of Russell Brand and David Walliams facing serious public scrutiny and consequences (a grave one soon to be revealed too!) over allegations and controversies surrounding their conduct. Against that backdrop, perhaps we should be encouraging a different kind of masculinity: one that celebrates women, recognises their talent and beauty, and isn't afraid to express admiration without needing to diminish or control them.

    There is a world of difference between objectifying a woman and celebrating her. Maybe Bono deserves a little credit for the latter, rather than being mocked for it.
  2. Originally posted by TheRefugee:Perhaps instead of slagging Bono for writing a song celebrating a woman like Rosalía, we should be applauding him.

    In a world where we are increasingly confronted with stories of powerful men abusing their positions and women, there is something refreshing about a man expressing admiration for a woman through his art.

    We have seen the likes of Russell Brand and David Walliams facing serious public scrutiny and consequences (a grave one soon to be revealed too!) over allegations and controversies surrounding their conduct. Against that backdrop, perhaps we should be encouraging a different kind of masculinity: one that celebrates women, recognises their talent and beauty, and isn't afraid to express admiration without needing to diminish or control them.

    There is a world of difference between objectifying a woman and celebrating her. Maybe Bono deserves a little credit for the latter, rather than being mocked for it.
    Exactly, very well said!!!

  3. This....... My biggest surprise of the album. Before hearing the album I thought that this song will be a low point but actually this song became one of the favorite on the first listen.
  4. Still haven't heard it yet, but great take by TheRefugee.
  5. Originally posted by TheRefugee:Perhaps instead of slagging Bono for writing a song celebrating a woman like Rosalía, we should be applauding him.

    In a world where we are increasingly confronted with stories of powerful men abusing their positions and women, there is something refreshing about a man expressing admiration for a woman through his art.

    We have seen the likes of Russell Brand and David Walliams facing serious public scrutiny and consequences (a grave one soon to be revealed too!) over allegations and controversies surrounding their conduct. Against that backdrop, perhaps we should be encouraging a different kind of masculinity: one that celebrates women, recognises their talent and beauty, and isn't afraid to express admiration without needing to diminish or control them.

    There is a world of difference between objectifying a woman and celebrating her. Maybe Bono deserves a little credit for the latter, rather than being mocked for it.
    👏👏👏👏
  6. This is my favorite track on theirs album, and I think it’s at least partly due to the fact that Rosalía is one of my other favorite artists. Genius recognizes genius.

    It’s also a rollicking rip-roaring track and just a lot of fun.
  7. Originally posted by dstankie:Rosalia names Patti Smith as one of her heroes and, as Aaron said, included a snippet of Patti from an interview in the 70s at the end of the song, La Yugular. Patti says this:

    "Seven heavens? Big deal. I wanna see the 8th heaven, 10th heaven, thousandth heaven. You know, it's like 'break on through the other side' it's just like going through one door. One door isn't enough. A million doors aren't enough."

    I'm not saying The Mirror Maker is a good or bad song (how can we judge something we haven't heard in full?), but I really don't think it's a cringy stalker thing. Bono is inspired by the artistic and spiritual questing he sees expressed in Rosalia's recent music.

    Rosalia is a lot more than the pop star of the moment. I'm not even sure Lux is a pop record. She sings in 14 different languages (though mainly Spanish, of course), there are lots of musical influences (flamenco, fado, classical, opera, pop, and more). And she studied a whole bunch of female saints from a variety of religious traditions whose lives/voices/inspirations found their way into all the songs on Lux, which itself is arranged into four movements. So Lux is incredibly conceptual and intellectually-grounded, yet it works as a whole and as its own artistic statement. It's not really like any other album and she is not really like any other artist--except in the sense of that artistic and spiritual questing. In that sense, her allies are other major artists (like Patti Smith) who find unique ways to express and explore similar themes.

    Finally, Bono was primed for this kind of adoration of a younger female artist. He, I think correctly, prophesied on a much-maligned U2 song that "women of the future hold the big revelations." Rosalia (as an artist) embodies that insight.


    I love this take.
  8. I think it’s also important to remember that they did, in fact, ask her for permission before recording and putting out a song about her. And per her appearance on The Tonight Show last month, it seems like she’s quite flattered by/grateful for it. If they didn’t get consent for it, that’d be a whole other issue.
  9. I'm sure it will be a banger live, especially for the outro alone.
  10. This, Go and Glorify are STUCK IN MY HEAD. This is a crazy song. Shouldn't work as well as it does. Adam goes crazy on the bass and they sound like they're having FUN
  11. Add me to the list of people that hated the idea behind this song and then comes back crawling in shame after listening in full.

    Wow, this is a banger and I hope they play it live.
    Chorus is catchy as hell, it has a structure that makes it super different to other U2 songs.
    A nice surprise
  12. Dear God they haven’t sounded this enjoyed and present in a song in years