1. Comfortably their greatest standalone song since Stay.

    (IMO of course).
  2. After silencio and street of dreams, I decided to wait until the album was released to listen to anything else. This song, and the video that accompanied it, have made me feel things I haven’t felt in a long time, or ever before. Absolutely amazing.
  3. The beginning of the vocal outro with the Edge (maybe a little autotune?) was nice. Hope they include that in stadium shows.
  4. Originally posted by pearlvr4:The beginning of the vocal outro with the Edge (maybe a little autotune?) was nice. Hope they include that in stadium shows.
    I loved that touch
  5. I cried listening to this live version
  6. Look at the number of comments and what people are saying. There clearly IS some kind of consensus on what makes a GREAT U2 song.

    I can’t think of any new U2 song that’s gotten this kind of response in YouTube comments since YouTube started. Not Magnificent. Not Song for Someone. Not Every Breaking Wave. Not anything from SOE or the EPs.

    The public has spoken.
  7. I think Edge by mistake in his guitar solo in around 5:19 to 5:21 gets a very high pitch sound, which sound incredible emotional and takes the atmosphere one step further. This has to be one of the better performances by the band.
  8. Originally posted by Peterrrrr:I think Edge by mistake in his guitar solo in around 5:19 to 5:21 gets a very high pitch sound, which sound incredible emotional and takes the atmosphere one step further. This has to be one of the better performances by the band.
    [YouTube Video]
    Great Edge!!
  9. I am still completely captivated by this song
  10. Me too , it should really make them feel that’s it not a bad thing to sound ‘like’ U2.
  11. For some reason the opening guitar reminds me of music from the movie Halloween. Kinda creepy.