1. The most significant change I’ve noticed on this album is that they’ve broken the formula. They typically relied on a song structure like that of "Beautiful Day," "With or Without You," or "Vertigo"—but that’s not really the case here. Tracks like "Go" or "Silencio" are highly unusual for U2; they are not interludes, they are full-fledged songs. Newer Bands: U2 has shifted their approach to song structure on this record. Gone are the epic bridges and the 40-second guitar solos—the kind where it feels like The Edge is about to transport us to paradise. "Silencio" is a prime example; while it’s not necessarily off-putting, those expecting the "old" U2 will need some time to adjust to this new version. Brian Eno: His influence is clear on the tracks he contributed to, pushing the band toward deconstruction—though on this record, it’s taken to the extreme. As The Edge hinted, it’s intentionally chaotic. I would have liked to see Eno take on a more comprehensive role across the entire album. Bono: It’s a nice touch that he uses vocal effects and, at times, speaks in the background—as he does on "The Mirror Maker." On *Songs of Experience*, he was almost always front and center; here, he’s more integrated into the band’s sound, helping to build atmosphere ("Go" is the perfect example). Newer Bands: The influence of groups like Fontaines D.C. explains why U2 decided to shake up their formula. If you were hoping for the kind of "fan service" found in their recent EPs—a nod to the "old" U2—you won’t find it here. The band is driven by an urgent, direct approach: short songs, a prominent bassline, and—to reiterate—a focus on delivering a punch rather than crafting an anthem. Geese: Perhaps the most notable influence; this band often shifts rhythms—sometimes three times in a single track—without any warning. U2 attempts something similar (though not quite to that extreme), and they make no apologies for it. No one would deny the legacy this band has built, but don’t expect that from this album—they’ve decided to adopt the formula used by newer bands (which, for me, is fine, as the EPs were already enough). It’s not that they’ve lost their touch; rather, the band wants to hold its own against these newer acts. The songs have a carnival-like quality—twisted, chaotic, short, and colorful—and if you don’t like one, just wait; an even shorter one is coming up. There’s something here that doesn’t quite sound like U2, yet at the same time, it does; to me, it’s an intriguing attempt to blend their past (think The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby) with the musical structures of today.
  2. Originally posted by flopro:[..]
    Maybe now solos out front, but definitely some interesting guitar work and licks overall, just not front and centre?

    Exactly
  3. I could be wrong, but given the recent interview and the admiration that Bono and The Edge have expressed for Fontaines D.C., along with these strange changes in the songs, I’ve arrived at this impression and analysis.

    still thinking the EP’s were Fan Service before this change
  4. Originally posted by Zwervervriend:I didn't bother to read all 200+ pages in this thread since yesterday. But the last few pages seems like that no one likes this album. Well, i do like it!! Is it as good as JT or AB? No way. But it's a huge step forward from the Songs of...garbage!! For now, i have no song i want to skip. With the Songs of, it was hard to find a single song that i didn't want to skip.

    My rank:
    AB / Pop
    JT
    Zooropa
    TUF
    HTDAAB
    NLOTH
    CdL
    War
    Boy
    R&H
    ATYCLB
    SOI
    October
    SOE
    SOS

    I’m with you, and if you do take the time to scroll further back you’ll see quite a lot of positive reactions.

    Too early for me yet, but I’d say my own ranking of the albums is similar to yours (though I’d put CdL above No Line and also bump up Boy and War). Agree in being happy that this album is a clear departure from the overproduced, overthought phase of SOI/SOE. They sound energized again.
  5. Originally posted by Damonio123:The most significant change I’ve noticed on this album is that they’ve broken the formula. They typically relied on a song structure like that of "Beautiful Day," "With or Without You," or "Vertigo"—but that’s not really the case here. Tracks like "Go" or "Silencio" are highly unusual for U2; they are not interludes, they are full-fledged songs. Newer Bands: U2 has shifted their approach to song structure on this record. Gone are the epic bridges and the 40-second guitar solos—the kind where it feels like The Edge is about to transport us to paradise. "Silencio" is a prime example; while it’s not necessarily off-putting, those expecting the "old" U2 will need some time to adjust to this new version. Brian Eno: His influence is clear on the tracks he contributed to, pushing the band toward deconstruction—though on this record, it’s taken to the extreme. As The Edge hinted, it’s intentionally chaotic. I would have liked to see Eno take on a more comprehensive role across the entire album. Bono: It’s a nice touch that he uses vocal effects and, at times, speaks in the background—as he does on "The Mirror Maker." On *Songs of Experience*, he was almost always front and center; here, he’s more integrated into the band’s sound, helping to build atmosphere ("Go" is the perfect example). Newer Bands: The influence of groups like Fontaines D.C. explains why U2 decided to shake up their formula. If you were hoping for the kind of "fan service" found in their recent EPs—a nod to the "old" U2—you won’t find it here. The band is driven by an urgent, direct approach: short songs, a prominent bassline, and—to reiterate—a focus on delivering a punch rather than crafting an anthem. Geese: Perhaps the most notable influence; this band often shifts rhythms—sometimes three times in a single track—without any warning. U2 attempts something similar (though not quite to that extreme), and they make no apologies for it. No one would deny the legacy this band has built, but don’t expect that from this album—they’ve decided to adopt the formula used by newer bands (which, for me, is fine, as the EPs were already enough). It’s not that they’ve lost their touch; rather, the band wants to hold its own against these newer acts. The songs have a carnival-like quality—twisted, chaotic, short, and colorful—and if you don’t like one, just wait; an even shorter one is coming up. There’s something here that doesn’t quite sound like U2, yet at the same time, it does; to me, it’s an intriguing attempt to blend their past (think The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby) with the musical structures of today.
    also, I don’t like "Midnight Sunshine." I would have included "Get Back To Now" instead…this one sounds great.
  6. Originally posted by onetreeman:Am I the only one who finds Glorify to be the most disappointing on the album? It has so much potential to be a rock n roll song with heavy guitar bass and drums, but they decided to go with the acoustic version? I would have loved to see them put a rock version on the album and then done a stripped down version on an acoustic album. It is definitely good, but I couldn't help feeling like I was waiting for it to become something bigger and it never did.


    For me this is typical gospel song. For me it is a banger even if production could have been better on the album. I think will be brillant on live

    Can t stop us for me is another brillant song but i doubt it will be good on live.

    My favorite song is la Reina but this bridge is too long and not good . By the way live will be perfect
  7. It’s a great album

    AB - JT
    Zooropa - Unforgettable Fire - War - Boy
    Rattle and Hum (studio songs)
    Carnaval de Luz (Deluxe)
    How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb
    All That You Can’t Leave Behind (Side A)
    Pop
    No Line On The Horizon
    Passengers
    SOI
    SOE
    October
  8. Originally posted by bpt3:[..]

    I’m with you, and if you do take the time to scroll further back you’ll see quite a lot of positive reactions.

    Too early for me yet, but I’d say my own ranking of the albums is similar to yours (though I’d put CdL above No Line and also bump up Boy and War). Agree in being happy that this album is a clear departure from the overproduced, overthought phase of SOI/SOE. They sound energized again.
    Glad to hear there are a lot of positive reactions 😀
  9. What are the odds Go isn’t played live and they walk out to it playing over the PA. It seems like its got so much going on might be tuff to perform anyways
    Kind of like FITB by Oasis
    They open with La Reina
  10. AB
    JT
    Zooropa
    War
    Unforgettable Fire
    Carnaval De Luz (Deluxe, very strong concept)
    Boy
    ATYCLB
    HTDAAB
    Pop
    SOI
    Rattle And Hum
    NLOTH
    October
    SOE

    Having listened to Carnaval De Luz repeatedly, I find it quite enjoyable. The only other album it truly rivals is How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb, like that record, it’s firmly rooted in rock, yet it’s unpredictable and avoids the same formula the band has been repeating for the last two decades. The Deluxe version is what really elevates it…the impeccable quality of the included EPs and the conceptual link they share with CdL easily place this release in the top tier.
  11. To be honest I think the EPs are much better than this LP. A third EP with TGSOE, Glorify, Silencio, La Reina and Get Back to Now would’ve been a better choice.