1. this album has its oddities, but all things considered, I think it’s the best work since 2004 or perhaps the best they could have possibly given us. It would be unfair to compare it to Achtung Baby or The Joshua Tree but it doesn’t even come close not by a long shot. Anyway, as I’ve said before, I think How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb is a fair comparison, given that the intentions behind both albums are very clearly defined.
  2. Achtung Baby
    The Joshua Tree
    The Unforgettable Fire
    Zooropa
    Pop
    War
    How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb
    All That You Can't Leave Behind
    Boy
    October
    Rattle and Hum
    No Line on the Horizon
    Songs of Innocence
    Carnaval De Luz
    Songs of Experience
    Songs of Surrender
  3. Really liking this album! One minor, tiny grip: I miss Edge's solos. It's like he's tried all he can to avoid that since forever.


    Last album with solos...No Line? I think.
  4. The Edge is absolutely anonymous on this album. Zero standout moments for him. I think it is quite shallow lyrically so far as well. Just lots of Bono by numbers. How vocals are decent though.

    Adam is absolutely incredible however. Just magic everywhere from him.
  5. I think he shines on this much more than recent albums. It’s all about the hooks as opposed to solos on this LP, that much is certain.
  6. His best moment here is probably La Reina, although that riff and song are unfortunately nowhere near as good as EBTTRT to which it’s often compared.

    His best moment recently was Song For Hal.
  7. Originally posted by eddiecanb:I think he shines on this much more than recent albums. It’s all about the hooks as opposed to solos on this LP, that much is certain.
    Yea it's all short little repetitive hooks of a few notes. It's just not to my liking. Quite a bit of it on the EP's as well.
  8. Originally posted by germcevoy:The Edge is absolutely anonymous on this album. Zero standout moments for him. I think it is quite shallow lyrically so far as well. Just lots of Bono by numbers. How vocals are decent though.

    Adam is absolutely incredible however. Just magic everywhere from him.
    yep. it's just a lot of mediocrity unfortunately. greatest show on earth is classic-worthy, some others may grow (glorify, or can't stop). what it comes down to for me personally is that there are not a lot of tracks on this lp that will be added to the u2 cannon. i would have loved to see otherwise but they might have overplayed their hands with releasing the best stuff on the eps.
  9. Originally posted by RememberEveryMoment:[..]
    yep. it's just a lot of mediocrity unfortunately. greatest show on earth is classic-worthy, some others may grow (glorify, or can't stop). what it comes down to for me personally is that there are not a lot of tracks on this lp that will be added to the u2 cannon. i would have loved to see otherwise but they might have overplayed their hands with releasing the best stuff on the eps.
    I concur so far. Nor would I care too much if there was a cohesiveness or an arc that I could decipher. But I’m not there yet. I’m glad it exists and will continue to keep digging.

    But for certain, GSOE is the only classic to be found here.
  10. I was more hyped for the tour announcement. The album is disappointing. Let's see what these setlists and performances are like.
  11. Originally posted by Welsh_Edge:I was more hyped for the tour announcement. The album is disappointing. Let's see what these setlists and performances are like.
    I suppose albums are just an excuse to go on tour without having to admit that you are a legacy act.
  12. Originally posted by Welsh_Edge:I was more hyped for the tour announcement. The album is disappointing. Let's see what these setlists and performances are like.
    Same here