1. Edge could have contributed more than just guitar. Like the songs melodies could have started on guitar by edge, a more traditional rock song but turned into this after the DJ processed the musical elements more.
  2. Doesn't really feel like a song for an international football tournament.


  3. Rioux did guitar on the track. The Edge did the main riff though.

    The YouTube credits don't include all the musicians and their roles. They don't credit Garrix or Bono with doing anything on the track either...

    The YouTube credits break out the writing / composer credits as well as additional musicians not credited as the "artist" on the track. The artist here is Martin Garrix, Bono and Edge, thus their individual contributions are not mentioned.
  4. Depends if you are looking at the "traditional fans" of an international football tournament. The fan makeup will continually evolve as those traditional fans fans get older and will need to be replaced with those that are younger. In the end its all about getting new eyes on the sport to sell advertising. Not saying this song will create a whole new generation of fans on its own, but anything that catches their ear/eyes that does not feel older/traditional can only help. They know that the traditional fans will watch regardless of the entertainment add-on.
  5. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]


    Rioux did guitar on the track. The Edge did the main riff though.

    The YouTube credits don't include all the musicians and their roles. They don't credit Garrix or Bono with doing anything on the track either...

    The YouTube credits break out the writing / composer credits as well as additional musicians not credited as the "artist" on the track. The artist here is Martin Garrix, Bono and Edge, thus their individual contributions are not mentioned.
    That's true, I was thinking the same thing. Bono's not credited for lead vocals but he is obviously the main singer on the track.
  6. Originally posted by LikeASong:The other thing I was expecting -and therefore I'm missing- is one last "punchier" chorus, maybe with some vocal choir or something. I could live with the song not going anywhere and with the rest of little things that don't convince me, but it would be much better if they had the obvious cliché of a children/female choir to boost the last chorus.

    I read this comment earlier and I wasn’t sure what side of things I was on. There is a part of me that would love the song to go even further but then I think that might be one of the things that makes it so good. As soon as the song finishes the first thing I think is I haven’t got enough of that and I want to play it again. It keeps me coming back for more and I don’t think that can ever be a bad thing with a song.
  7. Can’t we just use the World Cup where the streets have no name from 2011 or 2010 :/
  8. Also 48k updoots compared to 1k downdoots on YouTube is pretty reasonable for a song like this with U2
  9. I recall for the last album they wanted to release DJ remixes first but it wasn't able to happen... so could this be one of the new songs from the album (but just a remix version)....?
  10. It's just Bono and Edge not U2.