1. Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
    Thank you Drew, I’ve been saying this for years that by definition the band aren’t a heritage act. I don’t even think it’s a matter of opinion but factual that they aren’t a heritage act although I’ll likely get criticised for saying that but when something doesn’t fall in line with the definition of what they are saying surely that isn’t an opinion they’re just wrong with what they’re saying?
    Heritage might mean age/longevity in that sense. But it also means you're leaving something as-is.

    Everything you know is confusing.
  2. Originally posted by drewhiggins:[..]
    Heritage might mean age/longevity in that sense. But it also means you're leaving something as-is.

    Everything you know is confusing.
    What I think people are doing is using individual projects to define the band in general. Like the JT tour, ok it can be called a nostalgia tour, fair enough they’re touring an old album. But that didn’t make them a nostalgia act because they then went and did SOE and toured that. If they did the JT anniversary tour, didn’t release SOE and then just did Songs Of Surrender and had no intentions of a brand new album then yes they absolutely would have became a heritage or nostalgia act but that isn’t the case.
  3. Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
    What I think people are doing is using individual projects to define the band in general. Like the JT tour, ok it can be called a nostalgia tour, fair enough they’re touring an old album. But that didn’t make them a nostalgia act because they then went and did SOE and toured that. If they did the JT anniversary tour, didn’t release SOE and then just did Songs Of Surrender and had no intentions of a brand new album then yes they absolutely would have became a heritage or nostalgia act but that isn’t the case.
    Take a band that's been around for 30-50 years ...

    Judas Priest are playing the whole of British Steel (1980), GnR live off Appetite For Destruction (1987), Meat Loaf was playing Bat 1 (1977), the Rolling Stones played the whole of Sticky Fingers (1971), Aerosmith did the whole Toys In The Attic album (1975), Alanis Morrissete plays the whole of Jagged Little Pill (1995), U2 plays The Joshua Tree (1987) and so on.

    Some of them are releasing new albums, some new singles - etc etc and so on; some are playing residencies, some are playing albums in full. If you stay the exact same and live off past glories (one could argue all the above are), are they heritage? Age defines that, longevity defines that, staid/static/stuck - defines it too. Heritage in music is a bit of a rarity, when you consider these bands/artists of these eras.

    And if you're not into it - then I'm sure something will come out eventually you do like. I haven't liked anything since SoI (excepting Book Of Your Heart and The Little Things That Give You Away) - those aren't the works of a band in nostalgia. Same as I haven't liked anything Duran Duran have put out since 2010 (and I'm a big fan of them). Are they heritage? Maybe ... do they do anything to add to their legacy? Probably not, but it doesn't hurt having something there - you just don't have to notice/care for it. If this upcoming release adds nothing I care much for, it's there but will it worry me? No, because like SoE - it's 'there'.

    If they did the JT anniversary tour, didn’t release SOE and then just did Songs Of Surrender and had no intentions of a brand new album then yes they absolutely would have became a heritage or nostalgia act but that isn’t the case.

    I know there's one part of this I'd have rather they did, but they didn't. No matter - U2 aren't really bringing in new fans at this point, and if they are, it's hard to say what part of their time/output the 'new' fans will be into. Some might really like the 'college rock' part, others might like the AoR part, some might be into the alternative era(s) and who knows, some might really appreciate Womanfish.

    What fascinates me is - this band, that they have little control over their recording outputs or decisions? Guy Oserary/LN/Universal responsible for the 'last say'? Sure, they may be paying for the band and the rights, but ... I've never quite understood this when it comes to musical acts - not least U2 who've been around since 1980 - and 'The reason no one in this band has slave scrawled across their forehead ...

    and:

    '... I would like to ask the music business to look at itself and ask itself some hard questions. Because there would be no U2 the way things are right now. That's a fact. Only friends out here'.



    Now you think about it - who could you define as a heritage act?

    KISS!

    Psycho Circus
    Let Me Go, Rock 'n' Roll
    Take It Off
    Watchin' You
    Firehouse
    Makin' Love
    All The Way
    Cold Gin
    Say Yeah
    War Machine
    Lick It Up
    I Love It Loud
    Black Diamond
    Detroit Rock City
    Rock and Roll All Nite

    First song - 1974, most recent - 2009. In that very set from November 2021. And they'll likely not put out a new album because fans 'won't embrace new material', as per Paul Stanley. Aerosmith - a great band, but even with their most recent album - they stopped playing all but one song from it and even now that's not in their setlist - means their most recent setlist addition is from 2001. And they're unlikely to put out any more new music/singles/albums. So there's two 'heritage' acts, if we go on nostalgia alone.
  4. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:[..]


    AGREE! Like I said the band are damned if they do damned if they don't!
    However I will say that if this news is aside and seperate info from what Adam had been talking about 6 months ago I'm actually shocked. The band really has lost its creative spark and rehashing old songs is something that heritage rock acts do to sell albums that newer material won't.

    I have never thought of the band as an heritage act until now.

    Question. I wonder who the pusher of this recent narrative ( soppy love songs for movies / Indian themed collab to sell tickets and boast sales numbers / Netflix BIO / JT 16/19 / rehashed album of back catalogue etc .... ) has been. BONO ? THE EDGE ? GUY? UNIVERSAL RECORDS ? LIVE NATION?

    Curious as to what you guys think ?


    Several artists have done music for movies/soundtracks. So what? At what point would a band be allowed to have a bio made about about their history? Fifty years after starting? Sixty? When they're all dead? I may not be a big fan of the idea, but it's their choice. Shame on them for doing the JT30 tour. Also shame for doing the AB30 album and rehashing their old catalog with the SoS project. And what do the most heritage of heritage acts do? Plan to release a new album. Doesn't make much sense, does it? They're not a heritage act. If they want to look at old material and rework it, have at it if it keeps them interested and challenged. And rumors of a new album is icing on the cake. Hardly a heritage act
  5. Hoping for a proper studio version of With Or Without You (with the Shine Like Stars coda)....perhaps with an orchestral backing. That would be epic!
  6. Returning to the forum after a couple of days absence to discover this wasn't some April Fools gag. Holy crap Batman!!! 😮
  7. Originally posted by drewhiggins:[..]
    Take a band that's been around for 30-50 years ...

    Judas Priest are playing the whole of British Steel (1980), GnR live off Appetite For Destruction (1987), Meat Loaf was playing Bat 1 (1977), the Rolling Stones played the whole of Sticky Fingers (1971), Aerosmith did the whole Toys In The Attic album (1975), Alanis Morrissete plays the whole of Jagged Little Pill (1995), U2 plays The Joshua Tree (1987) and so on.

    Some of them are releasing new albums, some new singles - etc etc and so on; some are playing residencies, some are playing albums in full. If you stay the exact same and live off past glories (one could argue all the above are), are they heritage? Age defines that, longevity defines that, staid/static/stuck - defines it too. Heritage in music is a bit of a rarity, when you consider these bands/artists of these eras.

    And if you're not into it - then I'm sure something will come out eventually you do like. I haven't liked anything since SoI (excepting Book Of Your Heart and The Little Things That Give You Away) - those aren't the works of a band in nostalgia. Same as I haven't liked anything Duran Duran have put out since 2010 (and I'm a big fan of them). Are they heritage? Maybe ... do they do anything to add to their legacy? Probably not, but it doesn't hurt having something there - you just don't have to notice/care for it. If this upcoming release adds nothing I care much for, it's there but will it worry me? No, because like SoE - it's 'there'.

    [..]

    I know there's one part of this I'd have rather they did, but they didn't. No matter - U2 aren't really bringing in new fans at this point, and if they are, it's hard to say what part of their time/output the 'new' fans will be into. Some might really like the 'college rock' part, others might like the AoR part, some might be into the alternative era(s) and who knows, some might really appreciate Womanfish.

    What fascinates me is - this band, that they have little control over their recording outputs or decisions? Guy Oserary/LN/Universal responsible for the 'last say'? Sure, they may be paying for the band and the rights, but ... I've never quite understood this when it comes to musical acts - not least U2 who've been around since 1980 - and 'The reason no one in this band has slave scrawled across their forehead ...

    and:

    '... I would like to ask the music business to look at itself and ask itself some hard questions. Because there would be no U2 the way things are right now. That's a fact. Only friends out here'.



    Now you think about it - who could you define as a heritage act?

    KISS!

    Psycho Circus
    Let Me Go, Rock 'n' Roll
    Take It Off
    Watchin' You
    Firehouse
    Makin' Love
    All The Way
    Cold Gin
    Say Yeah
    War Machine
    Lick It Up
    I Love It Loud
    Black Diamond
    Detroit Rock City
    Rock and Roll All Nite

    First song - 1974, most recent - 2009. In that very set from November 2021. And they'll likely not put out a new album because fans 'won't embrace new material', as per Paul Stanley. Aerosmith - a great band, but even with their most recent album - they stopped playing all but one song from it and even now that's not in their setlist - means their most recent setlist addition is from 2001. And they're unlikely to put out any more new music/singles/albums. So there's two 'heritage' acts, if we go on nostalgia alone.


    Great post man , agree with everything you have mentioned here.
  8. Originally posted by drewhiggins:[..]
    Take a band that's been around for 30-50 years ...

    Judas Priest are playing the whole of British Steel (1980), GnR live off Appetite For Destruction (1987), Meat Loaf was playing Bat 1 (1977), the Rolling Stones played the whole of Sticky Fingers (1971), Aerosmith did the whole Toys In The Attic album (1975), Alanis Morrissete plays the whole of Jagged Little Pill (1995), U2 plays The Joshua Tree (1987) and so on.

    Some of them are releasing new albums, some new singles - etc etc and so on; some are playing residencies, some are playing albums in full. If you stay the exact same and live off past glories (one could argue all the above are), are they heritage? Age defines that, longevity defines that, staid/static/stuck - defines it too. Heritage in music is a bit of a rarity, when you consider these bands/artists of these eras.

    And if you're not into it - then I'm sure something will come out eventually you do like. I haven't liked anything since SoI (excepting Book Of Your Heart and The Little Things That Give You Away) - those aren't the works of a band in nostalgia. Same as I haven't liked anything Duran Duran have put out since 2010 (and I'm a big fan of them). Are they heritage? Maybe ... do they do anything to add to their legacy? Probably not, but it doesn't hurt having something there - you just don't have to notice/care for it. If this upcoming release adds nothing I care much for, it's there but will it worry me? No, because like SoE - it's 'there'.

    [..]

    I know there's one part of this I'd have rather they did, but they didn't. No matter - U2 aren't really bringing in new fans at this point, and if they are, it's hard to say what part of their time/output the 'new' fans will be into. Some might really like the 'college rock' part, others might like the AoR part, some might be into the alternative era(s) and who knows, some might really appreciate Womanfish.

    What fascinates me is - this band, that they have little control over their recording outputs or decisions? Guy Oserary/LN/Universal responsible for the 'last say'? Sure, they may be paying for the band and the rights, but ... I've never quite understood this when it comes to musical acts - not least U2 who've been around since 1980 - and 'The reason no one in this band has slave scrawled across their forehead ...

    and:

    '... I would like to ask the music business to look at itself and ask itself some hard questions. Because there would be no U2 the way things are right now. That's a fact. Only friends out here'.



    Now you think about it - who could you define as a heritage act?

    KISS!

    Psycho Circus
    Let Me Go, Rock 'n' Roll
    Take It Off
    Watchin' You
    Firehouse
    Makin' Love
    All The Way
    Cold Gin
    Say Yeah
    War Machine
    Lick It Up
    I Love It Loud
    Black Diamond
    Detroit Rock City
    Rock and Roll All Nite

    First song - 1974, most recent - 2009. In that very set from November 2021. And they'll likely not put out a new album because fans 'won't embrace new material', as per Paul Stanley. Aerosmith - a great band, but even with their most recent album - they stopped playing all but one song from it and even now that's not in their setlist - means their most recent setlist addition is from 2001. And they're unlikely to put out any more new music/singles/albums. So there's two 'heritage' acts, if we go on nostalgia alone.
    Kiss is not even a heritage band at this point. They are below that now. Half cover band that lip syncs that's on their 2nd farewell tour
  9. A clip of Bono calling the "War" album online "Surrender" has emerged. U2W1 did you know War's orginlal working title was Surrender?
  10. It’s not an opinion when it’s backed up with facts. It’s not an opinion to say 2+2=5, it’s wrong, as is calling U2 a heritage act based on the definition.
  11. Originally posted by miryclay:A clip of Bono calling the "War" album online "Surrender" has emerged. U2W1 did you know War's orginlal working title was Surrender?
    It hasn't "emerged", that interview is well known. Do you think it was the working title? I always thought it was just Bono's mind slipping.