1. Originally posted by germcevoy:If they’re willing to try this shit out then why not with new music? Why go back and dissect old well known songs that will just sound so jarring?

    I am baffled but as ever I will reserve judgement until I have consumed it and full and have the time to gather my thoughts.
    I'd always much rather have them record new music, but I'm starting to appreciate how much weirder this project is turning out to be than whatever it seemed like at first.
  2. Originally posted by Hansav:[..]
    I'd always much rather have them record new music, but I'm starting to appreciate how much weirder this project is turning out to be than whatever it seemed like at first.
    I’ll take weird all day long. Here’s hoping.
  3. Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
    If they’re willing to try this shit out then why not with new music? Why go back and dissect old well known songs that will just sound so jarring?

    I am baffled but as ever I will reserve judgement until I have consumed it and full and have the time to gather my thoughts.
    Maybe they feel there’s a difference between experimenting with a song that’s already gained a positive reputation and a brand new song that they want fans to get to know in the best form it can be, sometimes experimental isn’t best, quite often that can be the case. I doubt any of the band members think they’ve created the best versions of all these songs with these reworks, maybe some of the songs they’ll think that about but in general it’s just an alternative way to listen to them, very different to what they want to achieve with new songs.
  4. Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
    If they’re willing to try this shit out then why not with new music? Why go back and dissect old well known songs that will just sound so jarring?

    I am baffled but as ever I will reserve judgement until I have consumed it and full and have the time to gather my thoughts.


    Exactly...Leave the U2 legacy alone and use the creative energy to make fresh new U2 music.

    I can see maybe an album of 12 reimagined songs, perhaps selecting from deep cuts, but not 40 songs.

    Like I have said before and others have posted here, it will be worth it if they drop a banger of a rock album next.
  5. It’s the breadth of it. FORTY fucking songs. That’s a shit ton of work to try and produce something stripped back. I am confused but I am not yet disappointed.
  6. Originally posted by germcevoy:It’s the breadth of it. FORTY fucking songs. That’s a shit ton of work to try and produce something stripped back. I am confused but I am not yet disappointed.
    A lot of it was done during lockdown was it not so it’s more of a keep busy album which is encouraging especially when there’s a brand new album possibly less than a year away. Shows they still love doing what they do when they could have retired long ago.
  7. I'm listening Desire... also I heard they will make a ,,new direction,, 20th century fox music. Here is a sample



    If 40 songs will be on the same level... this will be the best album ever lol
  8. I think the acoustic direction is a product of the lockdown + Larry's absence. Not what I love about U2, but I'm glad it appears to be different from the majority of their work this century
  9. So if SOS 40 songs is kind of really weird and everything is weird, then what should we expect from the new album and Songs of Ascent? Something was reported about rock n roll or rocking, hard. I don't know where the journey with the music of U2 is going. It is better that way.


  10. Did you see my post about how on my iTunes purchase the album artwork is animated with each photo appearing in sequence?
  11. Yeah, but what would it mean? I mean it’s very deliberate