Originally posted by kris_smith87:[..]
I want them to ride off into the sunset with their tried and true message of love being bigger than anything in its way. I think turning around this whole message for an album would really be terrible.
Originally posted by kris_smith87:[..]
I want them to ride off into the sunset with their tried and true message of love being bigger than anything in its way. I think turning around this whole message for an album would really be terrible.
Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:I think anyone who believes that a band as old as U2 could still be part of the zeitgeist is deluding themselves. When bands get old they can do a few things. Continue to try and break new ground (for themselves), retire and leave their legacy intact, or do stuff like this album/the JT30 tour and start eroding their reputation.
I have to imagine that most U2 fans through the 80s and 90s (and even 2000s) never would’ve thought U2 would be a band who chose the third option.
More power to anyone who enjoys this recording, truly. It’s just not for me, and I don’t think it’s going to be for anyone other than those diehard U2 fans who are happy to see them cash in on their catalogue by doing stuff like this. I can safely say I never want to hear that version of Pride again. I’ll always want to hear the version that the band made in their 20s when it was revolutionary, and they were at the top of their game.
Originally posted by Unodostres123:[..]
I think it’s not quite as straight forward as that. Every move the band make could be seen as eroding their reputation. Retiring doesn’t mean you get to bank the reputation you have, people’s opinion of the band can still lessen as they do nothing. People who are fans eventually pass on and young people aren’t necessarily going to pay much attention to a retired band. Trying to break new ground also can lead to eroding their reputation, people might not like the results. And yes dong anniversary tours and releasing reworks stuff doesn’t appeal to everyone either. Ultimately they’ve just got to do what they enjoy doing and forget about pleasing other people, new material is on the way so they’ve not got all their eggs in one basket.
Originally posted by RUMMY:SOI > NLOTH > SOE
Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]
Fair points, though I will disagree that retiring wouldn’t have left their reputation/legacy intact. Sure artists may be forgotten about, but that’s inevitable. There are plenty of artists and bands who quit while they were ahead, and people look at their careers with nothing but fondness. People WILL look at U2’s (already do) as “that band who was once really innovative and popular but who later released some conventional and lesser albums”.
I can’t disagree that they should just do what they want - who the hell am I to tell them what to do and what not to do? But U2 are a band who live and die on the reception to their output. That’s always been very evident and even moreso after reading Bono’s memoir. It’s just odd that Bono is always going on about “why does anyone need another U2 album” and then they put this out lol. No one needed this.
Originally posted by Unodostres123:[..]
If there’s nobody around left to remember that band or artist that quit while they were ahead what reputation or legacy does that leave them with? I think in the bigger picture it’s all really insignificant what they do, certainly in the grand scheme of life but even in terms of the bands reputation. Once the band aren’t here or stop making music regardless of what’s gone on before people will just enjoy the bits they’ve always enjoyed. Do you not like pride anymore because of the choices the band have made? Do you like your favourite songs from the band less now?
Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]
I suppose I’m referring to the band’s output as a whole, not individual parts, but we can agree to disagree.
Personally though, this album and what I’ve heard of it is disappointing - and I mean that in terms of how it reflects against the rest of their career, and the actual artifact/recording itself. What I mean is, it’s not even as though it sounds good for what it is.
Originally posted by justinpushplay:Maybe.. and bear with me on this.. maybe they made this because they.. wanted to? Maybe they didn’t make it for sales or for relevance or to try to get a new audience, maybe they just enjoyed the idea and the process and they decided to share with us... frankly, I don’t wanna band that’s working for it’s fans. Of the segments of songs I heard on the audiobook, more interested me than not, so I’m curious about it. At the end of the day it’s just more of something. And I’d rather have more of a band I love than less. I happen to really like songs of innocence and songs of experience, but even those of you who only like one song or two on each album, aren’t you glad that you have that song? If the band had just stopped when a lot of you think, they should’ve, you’d be devoid of at least some thing you enjoyed, and that’s a strange mentality to crave. I’m glad I have songs like raised by wolves, and every breaking wave and red flag day and the little things that give you away...