1. Originally posted by Cask:[..]


    Unfortunately, this is what I feel as well. Very sad.... For me it is heartbreaking, just thinking what they were for me and now, no matter how much I try to like this stuff or really justify what they've been doing these past years (the lackluster anniversary releases, Sing 2 Soundtrack, uninspired fan club gifts, etc), it just doesn't click with me and bores me to death. The worst part of the Dirty Day version on E&I was Bono speaking all over it and yet he managed to have a show fully like that? I like my rock stars to sing, and play electric guitars, and bass and drums, not to tell stories while playing stripped down versions of their songs and then released an album like this.

    Hope they knock our socks out with their new album, but it is looking very doubtful at this point. Just as I didn't make any effort to attend any Bono Surrender show, will do the same if he and Edge decide to tour on this new collection.
    110% .. For a band with so much unreleased material, live vaults and the 'broken down' releases i.e. JT30 it is pathetic the stuff fans are getting😢

  2. to be fair that is his standard face
  3. Originally posted by grietim:Just enjoy some new takes on some old songs. You may like a few and dislike a bunch. The old ones always will exist. This isn’t some career defining moment….it’s just a release of some reworked tunes. Not that complicated. I don’t get the negativity.

    People want to be heard. Especially when they’ve got something negative to say. Disliking the project isn’t enough, they need to make everybody know how much they dislike it. As if the more publicly critical they are the more importance it puts on their opinion.
  4. Good lord people. This was something Edge started working on in 2019 and through COVID. It’s a collection of songs that tie to Bono’s new book. They’re not trying to reach to teens or a young audience. It’s literally a “hey look at we’ve been working on”

    They were bored during covid and changed up some of their hits. Who cares? If there were rumors of them doing these re-recordings but didn’t wanna release it, everyone would be complaining that they weren’t putting it out lol

    Sucks that U2 are in a lose lose situation with their fans no matter what they do.
  5. Originally posted by Release3:Good lord people. This was something Edge started working on in 2019 and through COVID. It’s a collection of songs that tie to Bono’s new book. They’re not trying to reach to teens or a young audience. It’s literally a “hey look at we’ve been working on”

    They were bored during covid and changed up some of their hits. Who cares? If there were rumors of them doing these re-recordings but didn’t wanna release it, everyone would be complaining that they weren’t putting it out lol

    Sucks that U2 are in a lose lose situation with their fans no matter what they do.
    Quite a bit of this but for what it sounds like and what it purports to be then I’d have liked to have seen this released a lot lot sooner than it is. If it’s three years in the making then it’s no longer a ‘covid project’ in my mind.

    My main worry as usual is that this ‘stripped back’ compilation will sound excessively complex and overworked. Hoping for the opposite and still reserving judgement.
  6. Originally posted by dylbagz:[..]


    Why? The music has been close to horrible since that point. I honestly wish they hadn't released a single song after 2014


    I really have no idea how you can say that and be on a U2 fan site? I mean if I was going on nearly a decade of hating music I would not be wasting my time posting here. That’s a lot of negativity to focus on. 🤷‍♂️
  7. Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
    Quite a bit of this but for what it sounds like and what it purports to be then I’d have liked to have seen this released a lot lot sooner than it is. If it’s three years in the making then it’s no longer a ‘covid project’ in my mind.

    My main worry as usual is that this ‘stripped back’ compilation will sound excessively complex and overworked. Hoping for the opposite and still reserving judgement.
    Well keep in mind that it was supposedly ready to be released at Christmas. (And it so should have been… would make a lot more sense to me!) many albums that were released in 2022 were considered “COVID records” meaning they started to come about during lockdown.
  8. Originally posted by kris_smith87:[..]


    I really have no idea how you can say that and be on a U2 fan site? I mean if I was going on nearly a decade of hating music I would not be wasting my time posting here. That’s a lot of negativity to focus on. 🤷‍♂️
    I mean I’ve been a fan of u2 since I was 3. And I agree, SOI was the last good music they made. That’s my opinion. I loathe SOE and SOS isn’t sounding like anything worthwhile. Throw in this “Vegas residency “, which is a term I never wanted to hear alongside u2 and it’s been a dark time for me personally. But I’ll always love this band , no matter what. Why can’t a fan be critical and still be a fan? I never understood this. Am I not a fan because I think SOE is trash? Should I only post here when I enjoy something the band does?
  9. I guess some fans don’t realize how lucky we are to have them still recording/Touring/being alive.
  10. U2's work after 2010 is like a four-door Porsche. It bears no likeness to what made them great. "But it has the same hood ornament, so it must be the same." It isn't. It's rubbish.
  11. Originally posted by Unodostres123:[..]

    People want to be heard. Especially when they’ve got something negative to say. Disliking the project isn’t enough, they need to make everybody know how much they dislike it. As if the more publicly critical they are the more importance it puts on their opinion.
    Exactly..... I don't expect it from U2 fans.
  12. Originally posted by Release3:Good lord people. This was something Edge started working on in 2019 and through COVID. It’s a collection of songs that tie to Bono’s new book. They’re not trying to reach to teens or a young audience. It’s literally a “hey look at we’ve been working on”

    They were bored during covid and changed up some of their hits. Who cares? If there were rumors of them doing these re-recordings but didn’t wanna release it, everyone would be complaining that they weren’t putting it out lol

    Sucks that U2 are in a lose lose situation with their fans no matter what they do.
    This