1. And you think U2 expects big sales from SOS ?
  2. Originally posted by ric:[..]
    Your angry response tells me you probably do 'give a crap' and you've essentially just 100% proved the point I was making in the third paragraph of my post...
    Hahahahahaha OK ric. Go mourn the band like a family member gone down the wrong path and write lengthy posts about it. That’s some passion you got there.
  3. I think they've shown incredible self-awareness despite perhaps being a little out of it as well. And to answer? No, I don't think they expect it to sell. But I think they may be overwhelmed by the negativity and may be shocked that it sells next to nothing, or 60% less of their projections. For their sake, I hope I'm wrong. To spend all this time on 40 songs and to see it crash and burn would be sad...but it's what I expect...and again, I hope I'm wrong!

    I just keep seeing people labeling this "potential turkey" as a cash grab, money maker, etc. When anybody with any knowledge of re-working albums should know they don't sell. Anybody own Natalie Merchant's new version of Tigerlily? Uh, umm, err..uh...no. Does anybody even know anybody who bothered with that one? Great album, but nope. What about Def Leppard's re-recording of Hysteria? I don't even think Def Leppard own a copy of it.
  4. I have not listened to tiktok bits. BD did not impress me, Pride is ok but love the last minute and i did enjoy ColbertWowy. I will keep an open mind.and will listen to the 40 songs.

    To me SOS is Edges covid project that is now getting a full on promotion (video, Leterman...). Pity since it could have been a fan club gift.
  5. Originally posted by pleasegone:[..]
    Though I agree with much/most of what you said...I keep seeing "Cash Grab" and "Cash In" as you called it. I've probably made around 23,000 posts on here highlighting that the absolute lowest selling album of not one, not two, not 50...but TONS of artists...their absolute worst selling album is the "reworking" of songs one. Or the "cover" album. Other than Rod Stewart, it is usually a very poor selling release.
    This is bound to not only be U2's lowest selling album, but by far...no, let me correct myself...by far far far far far. Even lower selling than SOI, which of course was given away. If they tried to give this thing away, they'd well...nobody would care. Just like nobody really cares about this thing. I just hope it's passable, and I'm surprised...but all these people talking about how U2 is in this for the money is PURE STAND UP COMEDY...this is no Cash Grab. It's like telling me a Steven King movie with Harrison Ford and Clint Eastwood playing in a Senior Basketball League was only done to grab some new fans...lol.
    But to me, it does seem like that. Would this album even exist if Bono hadn't just released his book? Would the book not have created enough revenue without being followed by an album? Was the book not good enough to stand alone without a U2 album? Why release an album of Bono and Edge essentially covering themselves on:

    Full 40 track Digital
    40 track 4 CD Super Deluxe Hardback Collector’s Edition;
    40 track 4 LP Super Deluxe Hardback Collector’s Boxset;
    20 track deluxe CD;
    16 track 180 gram black vinyl;
    16 track standard CD;
    and 16 track classic white cassette.


    I mean, what does that look like to you?! Or maybe it's just me... If it had been a low key release under the 'Bono & Edge' moniker then my opinion would be completely different but considering half the band aren't even on the album and they're selling U2 fans re-recorded U2 songs on loads of different (probably quite expensive) formats, I can only have the opinion I do...

    I'm not saying it will be a high selling album, that's neither here nor there. It's the fact it even exists and in so many formats under the U2 banner that I have a problem with.
  6. Originally posted by pleasegone:[..]
    I think they've shown incredible self-awareness despite perhaps being a little out of it as well. And to answer? No, I don't think they expect it to sell. But I think they may be overwhelmed by the negativity and may be shocked that it sells next to nothing, or 60% less of their projections. For their sake, I hope I'm wrong. To spend all this time on 40 songs and to see it crash and burn would be sad...but it's what I expect...and again, I hope I'm wrong!

    I just keep seeing people labeling this "potential turkey" as a cash grab, money maker, etc. When anybody with any knowledge of re-working albums should know they don't sell. Anybody own Natalie Merchant's new version of Tigerlily? Uh, umm, err..uh...no. Does anybody even know anybody who bothered with that one? Great album, but nope. What about Def Leppard's re-recording of Hysteria? I don't even think Def Leppard own a copy of it.
    I only ask because you seem all bent on sales.

    As for reception...this is an album of reworked songs. A once in a career move. Not sure what counts as a crash and burn ? This is not a new U2 album of fresh material.
  7. Originally posted by ric:[..]
    And what does that tell you? Do you think there might possibly be some correlation between the band's increasingly substandard output and the much larger than normal amount of negativity amongst its fanbase? Or do you think it's just a coincidence?

    I don't think you need to be a genius to work that one out...
    ‘Increasingly substandard’ is only a matter of opinion, the critics would do well to remember that. The only thing the amount of negativity suggests is that either quite a big percentage of fans aren’t keen on SOE or it could suggest that the percentage isn’t necessarily higher than normal but the dislike is stronger from they individuals than usual. Either way it still doesn’t prove quality. I think it is more of the latter tbh because the people who weren’t happy about an anniversary tour were probably amongst a lot of the SOE haters and that hate/dislike has multiplied, but it’s my belief that a lot of these critics are being irrational. They have some crazy principle about not celebrating the past which I personally find hilarious. It doesn’t prove passion to me it proves pettiness. What you are right about is people should be allowed to be negative as well but a lot of the negative people like to make sure they keep being negative as if to be heard louder than everyone else or as if they think it makes them more important or their opinion fact when it doesn’t.
  8. Originally posted by ric:[..]
    But to me, it does seem like that. Would this album even exist if Bono hadn't just released his book? Would the book not have created enough revenue without being followed by an album? Was the book not good enough to stand alone without a U2 album? Why release an album of Bono and Edge essentially covering themselves on:

    Full 40 track Digital
    40 track 4 CD Super Deluxe Hardback Collector’s Edition;
    40 track 4 LP Super Deluxe Hardback Collector’s Boxset;
    20 track deluxe CD;
    16 track 180 gram black vinyl;
    16 track standard CD;
    and 16 track classic white cassette.


    I mean, what does that look like to you?! Or maybe it's just me... If it had been a low key release under the 'Bono & Edge' moniker then my opinion would be completely different but considering half the band aren't even on the album and they're selling U2 fans re-recorded U2 songs on loads of different (probably quite expensive) formats, I can only have the opinion I do...

    I'm not saying it will be a high selling album, that's neither here nor there. It's the fact it even exists and in so many formats under the U2 banner that I have a problem with.
    But wait...who says this is Bono and Edge only? I agree Edge is the brains behind this one (producer, 40 letters etc) but i dont think that means Adam and Larry arent involved. Audiobook or SOS shows dont have to mean they are using the exact same versions.
  9. Originally posted by kris_smith87:[..]
    Hahahahahaha OK ric. Go mourn the band like a family member gone down the wrong path and write lengthy posts about it. That’s some passion you got there.
    Hmm

    I'd have expected a slightly more educated and considered series of responses from someone who claims to work in education...

    And before you accuse me of wasting my time coming on here, writing long posts and criticising the band who can do no wrong in your eyes, they've just released a 'new' album, it really doesn't take more than a few minutes of my time on an evening to leave a few opinions on my favourite U2 forum. And if typing here = time-wasting, you must've wasted a LOT more time than me posting all your thousands of positive posts on here over the years? It doesn't bother me but you can't have it both ways!
  10. Originally posted by Unodostres123:[..]
    ‘Increasingly substandard’ is only a matter of opinion, the critics would do well to remember that. The only thing the amount of negativity suggests is that either quite a big percentage of fans aren’t keen on SOE or it could suggest that the percentage isn’t necessarily higher than normal but the dislike is stronger from they individuals than usual. Either way it still doesn’t prove quality. I think it is more of the latter tbh because the people who weren’t happy about an anniversary tour were probably amongst a lot of the SOE haters and that hate/dislike has multiplied, but it’s my belief that a lot of these critics are being irrational. They have some crazy principle about not celebrating the past which I personally find hilarious. It doesn’t prove passion to me it proves pettiness. What you are right about is people should be allowed to be negative as well but a lot of the negative people like to make sure they keep being negative as if to be heard louder than everyone else or as if they think it makes them more important or their opinion fact when it doesn’t.
    Well obviously it is ONLY my opinion and I would never expect other people to have to share my views. I'm just sharing them on here and if people want to debate them (in a mature way) with me, then that's great! If they want to get upset about them and get all defensive then that's just sad and mildly amusing in equal measure.
  11. ………

    Yikes.


    So what tracks are people most looking forward to on SOS? The inclusion of the Little Things was a welcome surprise, although I do wish Moment of Surrender was included. Beautiful Day on Bono’s tour was really moving, as was With of Without You. Oh…and Dirty Day?? Bring it on
  12. Originally posted by muzika:[..]
    But wait...who says this is Bono and Edge only? I agree Edge is the brains behind this one (producer, 40 letters etc) but i dont think that means Adam and Larry arent involved. Audiobook or SOS shows dont have to mean they are using the exact same versions.
    I thought the general consensus was that they aren't (directly) involved? If they are then that makes calling it a U2 album slightly more legit I guess... I'd say they need to be playing on at least 80-90% of it to warrant that title though!