1. I don't know if it just seems to me that Bono's vocals are pretty bad in the 40 SOS tracks in the audio book? What happened to his voice? For once, I like the background music on With or without you. 2 months is still endless.
  2. I think it’s too much promotion in all honesty. I know they’ve got a business to run but the time they’re taking to dwell on this isn’t gaining them any positive momentum but rather slowly frustrating more and more fans by the looks of it. I know there will be plenty of fans who enjoy this stuff too and I suspect I’ll enjoy some of it but I’m not excited about the song reveals at this point, I just want to hear the songs and see what’s next for the band. I’m looking forward to the Disney plus gig but I’d rather have been listening to SOS for 2 months prior to it than only have the chance to hear the album on the same day as the documentary. It is what it is now, the decisions can’t be reversed but I think this should have been released with much less fuss and much less dragged out.
  3. With or Without you doesn't sound nearly as good on that clip as it does live in the book shows.
  4. I think it’s too much promotion in all honesty.


    I agree with this. This release would be fine with me (well, maybe--I still think most of the clips are dreadful) if it was quietly released as a side project of Edge and Bono. But it is being billed as a U2 release and is being promoted with way too much hype and commercialism.

    I think in general U2 management has been poor since Paul M. retired.
  5. I don’t understand why Bono thinks singing the entire thing at the bottom of his range = reinvention. Just sounds like the dynamics and emotion have been stripped of it. Should have just called it Without You
  6. And he's been singing a good chunk of the song quietly for years now..I really pray that all the hype and promotion for the release doesn't backfire - I can imagine a lot of criticism coming their way. Kind of a "if it isn't broken, don't try to fix it" thing. I like some of the clips I've heard, and I'm trying to hold judgement until I hear the whole thing. Like Vertigo - first guitar sounds good. Then the second guitar, or strings, kick in- think it sounds meh. Then something like Bad - I'm interested to hear that in its entirety, I thought it sounded good. We'll see in a few weeks. I hope the previews keep coming, they are appreciated.
  7. Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
    I don’t understand why Bono thinks singing the entire thing at the bottom of his range = reinvention. Just sounds like the dynamics and emotion have been stripped of it. Should have just called it Without You
    Sounds like he's sitting at the kitchen table singing quietly to himself!!
    I'll reserve judgement until I hear the full songs though. Just seems weird when I thought he sounded fantastic on his solo shows.
  8. Originally posted by Zoo_Station_DW:[..]
    Sounds like he's sitting at the kitchen table singing quietly to himself!!
    I'll reserve judgement until I hear the full songs though. Just seems weird when I thought he sounded fantastic on his solo shows.
    There is not a chance he's gonna try taking on 25 year old Bono in the vocal department if he did try that it would end badly also what's the point in trying to copy the original versions of the songs that's not what they are trying to achieve with this album.
  9. I’m left wondering where that tour voice came from. Few could deny that it was the best shape we’ve heard him in for a long time. These studio recordings are somewhat lacking.
  10. I was looking at the With Or Without You preview, then clicked through a few other U2 albums, and it looks like Apple is adding animated covers. Pretty neat! I don't know if this is new or not, just thought I'd point it out while it's still semi on-topic.
  11. Originally posted by SlightedRadio91:I was looking at the With Or Without You preview, then clicked through a few other U2 albums, and it looks like Apple is adding animated covers. Pretty neat! I don't know if this is new or not, just thought I'd point it out while it's still semi on-topic.
    I noticed that with Pride.