Originally posted by dstankie:When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?
2004, with the Mercy demo leak
Originally posted by dstankie:When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?
Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
Agreed. The Colbert performance of With Or Without You in particular was astonishingly good. I was hoping for a taste of that here but the "singing at the kitchen table" comment is pertinent - I don't expect him to bring his Madison Square Garden voice, but maybe something in between where he doesn't sound like he's about to snooze off.
Originally posted by marik:[..]
I see a bunch of comments like this, so I just picked one to respond to.
I'm not trying to change anyone's opinions- you can have at 'her. But I thought I'd just share how I see this all, still with some enjoyment.
Re: his voice, I remind myself these were recorded largely in 2019, coming off the 2018 tour that he had a significant vocal issue. Whereas, the glorious WOWY Colbert performance and book tour shows are all in Nov 2022 after a 3yr vocal break.
That said, I also read into the many interviews, and book, where Bono has praised Sinatra specifically, for singing the same song at different ages, and his changing voice reflecting the change in person/age/experience. Bono seems to be very interested in that idea. And Edge's SOS fan letter seems to emphasis this idea as well, by mentioning songs changing over the yrs and specifically Bono's voice changing.
So, it's clear to me that that is the experiment they were going for. They didn't want to record another Pride with a soaring emotional vocal. They already did that. So what would be different to that? He can't go any higher. Lower-registrar. Less soaring. More speaking. And because most of U2 songs originally were passion/emotion-filled vocals, it means the different route to take, means less of that.
Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love that Colbert performance and still listen to it every few days since Nov. And I was even originally hoping that arrangement would be used on SOS. But I am still finding enjoyment hearing this new SOS clip of WOWY, because it sounds like someone who knows he's toward the end of his life. His life energy is dwindling. The drummer is slowing. That passion of life captured in early vocals like Pride or WOWY has dimmed over 40yrs of life. Personally, I can relate to alot of that feeling with where I am in my life now.
I realize alot of people wanted songs re-imagined in the vein of BBC Abbey Road songs. And I agree that would be awesome. But I see for this, they were looking more towards something like the SOI busker versions, but less sparse musically.
Originally posted by dstankie:[..]
When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?
Originally posted by dstankie:[..]
Exactly. His vocal performances are . . . . . . .
When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?
Originally posted by marik:[..]
I see a bunch of comments like this, so I just picked one to respond to.
I'm not trying to change anyone's opinions- you can have at 'her. But I thought I'd just share how I see this all, still with some enjoyment.
Re: his voice, I remind myself these were recorded largely in 2019, coming off the 2018 tour that he had a significant vocal issue. Whereas, the glorious WOWY Colbert performance and book tour shows are all in Nov 2022 after a 3yr vocal break.
That said, I also read into the many interviews, and book, where Bono has praised Sinatra specifically, for singing the same song at different ages, and his changing voice reflecting the change in person/age/experience. Bono seems to be very interested in that idea. And Edge's SOS fan letter seems to emphasis this idea as well, by mentioning songs changing over the yrs and specifically Bono's voice changing.
So, it's clear to me that that is the experiment they were going for. They didn't want to record another Pride with a soaring emotional vocal. They already did that. So what would be different to that? He can't go any higher. Lower-registrar. Less soaring. More speaking. And because most of U2 songs originally were passion/emotion-filled vocals, it means the different route to take, means less of that.
Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love that Colbert performance and still listen to it every few days since Nov. And I was even originally hoping that arrangement would be used on SOS. But I am still finding enjoyment hearing this new SOS clip of WOWY, because it sounds like someone who knows he's toward the end of his life. His life energy is dwindling. The drummer is slowing. That passion of life captured in early vocals like Pride or WOWY has dimmed over 40yrs of life. Personally, I can relate to alot of that feeling with where I am in my life now.
I realize alot of people wanted songs re-imagined in the vein of BBC Abbey Road songs. And I agree that would be awesome. But I see for this, they were looking more towards something like the SOI busker versions, but less sparse musically.
Originally posted by dstankie:[..]
When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?
Originally posted by dstankie:[..]
When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?