1. Originally posted by trainmaniac:[..]
    This is fundamentally a matter of opinion. In my perspective, their major achievement this past few years has been with tunes like Troubles, Crystall Ballroom, Reach Me Now, Little Things, Blackout, most of them could be out of the 90s.
    Sleep like a baby sounds like a Pop leftover. Love it
  2. Can they be uninhibited? Check out the new Yo La Tengo record for a band who has been around for decades letting loose... When asked about the record.. the band simple said this is what they found song wise when they got together and played. There was no overarching narrative BS.

    Could U2 just get in a room and play together without the pretense of saying "what we need to do is just getting in a room and playing together.. rediscovering what it means to be in a band like the old days.. Patti Smith reference insert, etc.".
  3. Originally posted by vertigone160:The key for me is I’d like most of the album to sound like the 4 band members playing together. Songs created that they could take to the live performance without having to worry about backing tracks etc because essentially it’s just 4 guys playing their instrument. I think they’re more likely to recapture some of the magic from the earlier days like I will follow, gloria, 11 o’clock tick tock, than they are to recapture the magic of zoo station, Zooropa, Mofo.


    +1 from me. The best rock album they could make is one stripped of the layers; something they could easily reconstruct on stage.
  4. Originally posted by dstankie:I can't be excited for a rock record by guys in their 60s. Good lord. They haven't pulled off "rock" as such since the 90s. And being in their 30s, they were pushing it then.

    I'd MUCH rather hear something spare and surprising--something that puts vulnerability and uncertainty at the center of things. The last thing anyone needs is another obvious U2 song with Bono pontificating. Book of Your Heart is the right direction.

    I will gladly eat all my words about how crap SOS is if it happens to provide a bridge for Edge and Bono to get away from the baggage of 40 plus years of themselves and discover a new country.

    I’m with you here, though the “vulnerability and uncertainty” that you hope for is what I’m personally enjoying about some of these SOS versions so far, too.
    But yes, “discovering a new country” is what they need at this point, not another rock album retread of the last 20 years.
  5. I don't understand the love for Fez...sounds like half baked Zoo TV nonsense. Now Being Born is epic, one of the best songs on NLOTH, but Fez? Rubbish, and I hardly ever call anything by U2 rubbish...well, maybe Auto Tune Is All We Have Left...
  6. Originally posted by pleasegone:[..]
    I don't understand the love for Fez...sounds like half baked Zoo TV nonsense. Now Being Born is epic, one of the best songs on NLOTH, but Fez? Rubbish, and I hardly ever call anything by U2 rubbish...well, maybe Auto Tune Is All We Have Left...
    Hmm all this time I thought it was a guy named Fez being born - same song
  7. I always thought Fez was the intro, and Being Born was the actual song. I could be wrong. I used to study the band like my life depended on it. By the time 2009 got here, I was pushing 40, and had a lot of other things on my mind. I still was pretty hardcore, going to as many shows as I could, and listening to their music almost as much as Prince, but not quite that much.