1. Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]
    True dat.

    I’d honestly argue that a few of those you named are better on the records .

    I do miss the harmonies (single version aside) and the big finale on the studio version of Streets though.
    Streets was the main one I was hinting at. As transcendent as it is Live, the version on record is just stupendous. I still struggle with believing Bono stood in a booth and delivered that vocal. The rhythms of Larry and Adam stir the tummy. Masterpiece.
  2. Originally posted by GayThePrayAway:[..]


    Hot take but i personally think they have never quite matched The Fly and Discotheque studio versions (as amazing as both are live)

    The closest they have come to it is Boston 01 and Chicago 2005/9/20
    The Fly from the AB30 release is as close as it gets to the studio version. Unreal.
  3. Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
    Streets was the main one I was hinting at. As transcendent as it is Live, the version on record is just stupendous. I still struggle with believing Bono stood in a booth and delivered that vocal. The rhythms of Larry and Adam stir the tummy. Masterpiece.
    Yeah, we sometimes get blinded by the live versions and forget how great are these songs on the records. What about Still Haven't Found? That vocal is absolutely unreal, so much intensity from literally the first verse. In fact the vocals on the opening trio of JT are hard to believe.
  4. At the moment I prefer for most of the U2 songs the albumversions. After decades being a U2 live fan, I did get somewhat bored. Especially after the JT tour, my opinion is that U2 live is on the automatic pilot. Sadly.
  5. There is actually a few songs that I like the live and studio versions quite equally with different strengths for each but in terms of stand out studio stuff another time Another Place I think is at its best on boy, shadows and tall trees, stories for boys. From October probably rejoice and then tomorrow my favourite version is the common ground remix, that is maybe my favourite studio rework. Like a song better studio but only up against 1 live performance with an average recording, TUF I’d say TUF itself is better on the album and Indian summer sky. JT I’d go I still haven’t found what I’m looking for, running to stand still, red hill mining town and one tree hill. All have great live versions but I’d definitely pick the studio versions of them first. And last album for now rattle and hum I’d go Angel of Harlem.
  6. Originally posted by ferrari:At the moment I prefer for most of the U2 songs the albumversions. After decades being a U2 live fan, I did get somewhat bored. Especially after the JT tour, my opinion is that U2 live is on the automatic pilot. Sadly.
    I understand you, and many times I've felt the same. My solution was to start listening only to random songs from random bootlegs. Sometimes I won't listen to any live U2 for weeks. And then when I do for whatever reason (usually having to check/upload something for U2start, or just stumbling upon a surprising fact/snippet while randomly browsing U2gigs) it always sounds fresh and exciting again.
  7. Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    Yeah, we sometimes get blinded by the live versions and forget how great are these songs on the records. What about Still Haven't Found? That vocal is absolutely unreal, so much intensity from literally the first verse. In fact the vocals on the opening trio of JT are hard to believe.
    The opening 3 suffered the most live after '89 imo, which is understandable because these studio vocals are so great. Still haven't found for me is an example of a song that live never came close the album version
  8. Probably a lot of the live vs studio preference comes down to the importance of each musical factor. Is vocal more important than the music, equal weighted etc. My favourite versions of streets and WOWY aren’t from the 80’s, the zoo tv versions and elevation versions of streets are top for me and for WOWY it’s zoo tv but specifically the earlier tour versions, the Sydney version is dreadful, and again elevation tour but particularly Slane. I think both have never been the same since after elevation albeit there’s still some good performances just not with quite the same energy.
  9. Originally posted by melon51:[..]
    The opening 3 suffered the most live after '89 imo, which is understandable because these studio vocals are so great. Still haven't found for me is an example of a song that live never came close the album version
    Yes to everything (although I'll debate Zoo TV as being the all time peak for Streets).
  10. Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
    Streets was the main one I was hinting at. As transcendent as it is Live, the version on record is just stupendous. I still struggle with believing Bono stood in a booth and delivered that vocal. The rhythms of Larry and Adam stir the tummy. Masterpiece.

    100% - there's a reason it's still my favourite song of all time, recorded version or otherwise 🙂

    Hell, even the video still puts a huge smile on my face

    Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    Yeah, we sometimes get blinded by the live versions and forget how great are these songs on the records. What about Still Haven't Found? That vocal is absolutely unreal, so much intensity from literally the first verse. In fact the vocals on the opening trio of JT are hard to believe.

    100%

    I honestly think there's an argument to be made for Still Haven't Found being (objectively - if art can be that 😛) their all-time greatest song/recording. The arrangement/recording is sublime, the lyrics are timeless and universal, it's incredibly catchy and easy to sing along to, it kinda has everything.
  11. Totally agree on Still haven’t found, has to be the one of the few studio versions I prefer
  12. Everything about the recorded Still Haven’t Found is a damn work of art. The vocals, instrumentation, the video…it’s so good.

    I’m still partial to Streets live. That version on the Slane Castle film is magic.