In my humble opinion, we could not have received this material and continue with video remasters and vinyl releases on record store day.
It's the kind of album that the band had never decided to make. Music without artifice. Bono's voice is recorded, in many cases, in a shot.
They have done what they wanted to do. The production is by The Edge and they had been asked many times to publish their ideas and put aside overproduction.
The 40 new acoustic songs don't convince me. Well the Remy that showed us at Apple music. With some songs Bono sounds sniffy, then his voice is much too high and then something happens with the microphone. You will not be able to make an overall judgment until March 17th. Desire has been completely ruined. Also the double voiced passages with the Edge in many songs sound very strange and wondrous.
A bunch of the songs are appealing and interesting and really do find other colors/feelings.
You know? Upon hearing all the snippets on Apple, I truly felt compelled by quite a few of the tunes (clearly not all of them, mind you.)
I believe I could eventually make a pretty decent 20-song playlist out of the ones I liked the most and have it there whenever I want to chill listening to some acoustic U2 renditions.
With all the thousand reservations I've had about it, today's the most excited I've felt regarding SOS. And it's a really nice feeling.