1. -- offtopic
  2. Originally posted by germcevoy:The first show with Larry back will be a hot ticket. I’d like to think the fans attending that show will make it loud and obvious that Larry is the U2 drummer.

    I don’t think the Vegas shows are for the audience anyway.


    U2 are always going in for it to the audience on their lives shows....
    I don't see why they wouldnt on those upcoming shows....
  3. Originally posted by Peterrrrr:[..]


    U2 are always going in for it to the audience on their lives shows....
    I don't see why they wouldnt on those upcoming shows....
    BVDB also hits the skins far too hard with the drum sticks. I think everyone will be surprised. I don't think he'll get the realistic drum sound of Larry Mullen Junior. It's the details that will bother him. The details of playing certain sequences and combinations require a great deal of skill. The fact is it won't be drumming like we know it from Mullen live and on the CD's and like everyone is used to it.
  4. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    BVDB also hits the skins far too hard with the drum sticks. I think everyone will be surprised. I don't think he'll get the realistic drum sound of Larry Mullen Junior. It's the details that will bother him. The details of playing certain sequences and combinations require a great deal of skill. The fact is it won't be drumming like we know it from Mullen live and on the CD's and like everyone is used to it.
    We have never heard Bram drum a U2 song, so let's just wait and see! 🙂
  5. In principle, BVDB only plays or covers Mullen's. He also doesn't have the memory of Mullen as he plays it. Likewise, BVDB will have problems with the shaker/rattle.
  6. I actually hope that BVDB doesn't sound the same as Larry Mullen (whose drumming I absolutely love).
  7. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    BVDB also hits the skins far too hard with the drum sticks. I think everyone will be surprised. I don't think he'll get the realistic drum sound of Larry Mullen Junior. It's the details that will bother him. The details of playing certain sequences and combinations require a great deal of skill. The fact is it won't be drumming like we know it from Mullen live and on the CD's and like everyone is used to it.
    U2 have been working with the guy since January. They chose him because they thought he could do the job. He’s had the benefit of actually working with Larry Mullen for a large chunk of that time, something most people attempting to sound like Larry would never have. At this point I think it’s just ignorant to judge what he is going to sound like having not heard a single performance since he’s had months of practice and work on all this.

    Do we have issues with Terry Lawless trying to play things The Edge or Brian Eno have come up with in studio?

    Finally U2 themselves mix up their own sound when they do stuff live. Did Larry on “I’ll Go Crazy” sound like Larry on the album?
  8. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    BVDB also hits the skins far too hard with the drum sticks. I think everyone will be surprised. I don't think he'll get the realistic drum sound of Larry Mullen Junior. It's the details that will bother him. The details of playing certain sequences and combinations require a great deal of skill. The fact is it won't be drumming like we know it from Mullen live and on the CD's and like everyone is used to it.
    If 1 drummer in the world hits hard, it's Larry.
  9. When we were close to the E-Stage in 2018, I couldn't believe how hard Larry actually hit those drums on Elevation and Vertigo. I've never experienced a drummer hitting the skins that hart.
  10. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    In principle, BVDB only plays or covers Mullen's. He also doesn't have the memory of Mullen as he plays it. Likewise, BVDB will have problems with the shaker/rattle.
    Again: We have never heard Bram drum a U2 song, so let's just wait and see!
  11. I'm with you on this and am keeping an open mind that "different" doesn't automatically equate to something negative and inferior. One of the highlights of following U2, and indeed one of my expectations of all artists I follow, is that the live version doesn't sound like a perfect recreation of the album, Nor does it have to sound like it did on a previous tour. Even if we all leave with the view that Larry does it better, it's not going to be the disaster some people seem to be predicting. He's a professional muso, so he's going to be close to how Larry plays. It's not as if we're getting someone with my level of incompetence behind the kit.
  12. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    In principle, BVDB only plays or covers Mullen's. He also doesn't have the memory of Mullen as he plays it. Likewise, BVDB will have problems with the shaker/rattle.
    Unless you have been drumming for a long time, you're really not qualified to make an assessment like this. Nine months is more than enough time to get at least 20 songs down. Even Larry has changed drumming approaches to several of their songs when you compare them to the album versions