1. Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
    A disposable song for promotional purposes. See it as just that and it will likely make the song more enjoyable for you.


    U2 doesn't make disposable songs. They only make what Bono considers to be "great" songs. The fact that he thinks this is great should tell you something. Look at this song for what it is - it's the tea leaves that you need to read about the future of this band.

    This is the first indication of their new studio direction since Songs of Experience came out. I like SOS for what it was - a pandemic project to spice up the oldies with a fresh take but nothing revolutionary. But when it comes to a new studio album, sound and theme, we've been in waiting mode until now. Welcome to the new U2. Now we know what we're in for.


  2. I think it was the Larry Ramones shirt or the Edge Wah during the solo. Also the image on Edge's jacket could be a sign.

    I actually hear some bizarre Beatles instrumentation in the bridge.
  3. Originally posted by BloodyValentine:[..]
    Yeah. Everything about this song is reasonable. As others have said, it's basically Joey Ramone Part 2.

    Half way through hearing this for the first time I thought, yep, that's it, U2's masterpieces are relegated to the rear view mirror now. They're either no longer surrounded by good advice, which I'm surprised by, or they've just become too comfortable from all the rehashes of their back catalogue that they don't know what a fresh direction would sound like any more. Disappointed doesn't even begin to describe what I'm feeling now. It feels like the end of this band for me. I think they're done.


    They just played the first note together in public in almost four years together and you say they are done?
  4. Not getting this Joey Ramone comparison. Joey is basically all power chords, this is not. Really enjoying it is far, looking forward to the studio version.
  5. Originally posted by miryclay:[..]


    I think it was the Larry Ramones shirt or the Edge Wah during the solo. Also the image on Edge's jacket could be a sign.

    I actually hear some bizarre Beatles instrumentation in the bridge.
    Will be interesting to hear Adams Bass at that part.
  6. As far as I can tell, rock is dead (and has been for some time). I don't know what to call this style of song, but U2 have been doing it for two decades now. The weirdest thing for this old timer is that the Edge seems to do little but play electric guitar nowadays in ways that sound like lots of other people playing electric guitar. Sometimes this really works (e.g. Red Flag Day). But he used to play like no one else and in fact really go out of his way to deconstruct the electric guitar. Also strange to me: Bono can't seem to move past platitudes and tired rhymes half the time in his lyrics. Take your pick of songs from the first 20 years and try to find anything as uninspired as "I'm free/Where you are is where I'll be."

    To Valentine's point, how can they not see what a diminishment this is creatively?

    I hear all your objections already: at least they're still together and making music... It's not that bad... The bass part is cool... Edge's solo (though it's way too short to be called a solo) has some great energy...It's just a fun song for the Vegas residency...Don't be so negative...

    Thought experiment: Would it really have been better if the Beatles had stayed together and made mediocre albums for the next thirty years?
  7. no offence but i really hate 'sliding doors' questions

    if i turned right instead of left then...

    NO you turned right

    the Beatles split - they ended because they no longer got on

    U2 have always had a better band relationship

    so they either can't stop making music or can't stop making money

    the music they make (these days) feels so generic (well, not all - just 90% to be fair) compared to their magnum opus days

    you're dead right about Edge - he's regressed with his guitar playing, which seems odd

    the latest single i gave a 6 now i'm thinking that was too generous - a 5 seems more fitting

    it was great to see the boys on that truck once more though - Bono and Edge are still legends (and the other 2 aren't that bad either)
  8. How has the edge regressed hahahaha

    Do you sleep with him or something? How would you know this
  9. I wouldn't say The Edge has 'regressed', but it's certainly been a while since we've had a U2 single that was defined by his distinctive style of playing.
  10. Originally posted by DeeGuy:Not getting this Joey Ramone comparison. Joey is basically all power chords, this is not. Really enjoying it is far, looking forward to the studio version.
    I think you are talking about Johnny Ramone.
  11. I went about this in depth some time ago in some other topic, can't find it now. But as a guitar player myself I can definitely say that The Edge has, indeed, regressed in his guitar playing – both at execution and imagination levels.

    He used to be groundbreaking and have truly memorable parts in terms of sound, composition and purpose to the song.

    Nowadays he's as generic as it gets with his new parts, nothing really sticks out anymore, and he's also been getting lazier and lazier in his playing (Invisible solo anyone?), relying more each time on backing tracks and simplifying some of his older parts. And last but not least: the mistakes He's always been sliiightly on the sloppy side of playing but from 2009 he's been making more and more mistakes. They're usually pretty subtle and most of the audience won't ever notice, but for guitar geeks like myself they are pretty obvious.
  12. No Line on the Horizon was the last time The Edge sounded like The Edge, in my opinion.

    I suppose as late as 2010 when they were experimenting with North Star and Every Breaking Wave. That's probably the last time I heard a new U2 song and thought it still sounded like the U2 I love, whether or not the songs were their absolute best.

    On one hand, I actually really like the Blondie ripoff. Who cares? It's great. U2 SHOULD be blatantly trying to have fun with '70s rock - it'd be a welcome change of pace from the 6,000 page life story Bono's been trying to read us via their performances on the Innocence & Experience tours.

    On the other hand, as others have mentioned, when their last studio album was full of rehashes of their next-latest material, and included guitar parts straight-up lifted out of other artists' songs, its hard to consistently swallow from a band this historically great.

    Atomic City is totally fine; it's probably, sadly, better than anything they've offered as a single, other than Invisible or The Blackout, in the last 13 years. But it in no way resembles the inspiring, anthemic, sonically interesting U2 that I (and many of us) fell and stayed in love with. Two-note Edge guitar parts that simply follow the chord roots, and Bono talk/shout singing has all run its course for me.

    The filler songs on U2 albums up until SOI aren't even this straightforward and plain.

    Will be happy to see them continue to play older material. They remain masters of the live environment, and evoking a reaction / emotional response. But I unfortunately feel like I'm gravitating toward the camp of people who don't really need any more from U2 if this is what they're going to keep doing.

    Would also love for them to stop trying to reinvent the wheel and sit down for a few months and let a few more "Moment of Surrender"s happen.