Originally posted by Sydney_MIke:Agree, judging a song based on some audio from a video of the band recording a video for there new audio really isn't giving it much of a chance is it? Let's just wait until the official track hits the streaming services.
i agree, we should listen first an official release, and then comment.
Let’s make something clear right away - whenever the new U2 album comes out, many people won’t like it. Any positive reaction will be overshadowed by a flood of complaining from fans unable to accept that the band’s sound, interests, and ambitions evolve over time. It happened every time U2 put out new music over the last decade, it will happen again. The new album won’t sound much like Achtung Baby or The Joshua Tree - the sooner some people accept it, the less disappointed they will be when it comes out. There are actually some of us who find a lot to enjoy in later period U2 and all of us would probably be better off if fans who don’t think the band released anything of value in the last 25 years accepted that they’re setting themselves up for disappointment yet again.
Originally posted by Hansav:Let’s make something clear right away - whenever the new U2 album comes out, many people won’t like it. Any positive reaction will be overshadowed by a flood of complaining from fans unable to accept that the band’s sound, interests, and ambitions evolve over time. It happened every time U2 put out new music over the last decade, it will happen again. The new album won’t sound much like Achtung Baby or The Joshua Tree - the sooner some people accept it, the less disappointed they will be when it comes out. There are actually some of us who find a lot to enjoy in later period U2 and all of us would probably be better off if fans who don’t think the band released anything of value in the last 25 years accepted that they’re setting themselves up for disappointment yet again.
I think the last three U2 records are better than the first 3. War is amazing but No Line, Innocence and Experience I find miles better than Boy and October
again the forum police telling us that we can't say anything negative about the band
get lost - we don't tell you that can't say anything positive
all members on this forum are entitled to their OWN opinion and if you can't accept that then find something else to focus your attention on - like knitting or making quilts
the song is just meh sounding from the videos - but if it does sound like the greatest single the band has ever released then i'll eat my beanie hat and post the video on here
regardless of the meh song - it's always great to see the band back together but not necessarily watching them selling their contracted souls in such a cringe-worthy manner
Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
I think the last three U2 records are better than the first 3. War is amazing but No Line, Innocence and Experience I find miles better than Boy and October
I can’t imagine why anyone would lash out at someone because they don’t like something the band is doing. Everyone has their own opinion. When I see an opinion I disagree with I just …..move on. There’s nothing in me that makes me when to respond and claim that persons feelings are wrong.
Gavin’s comments on Saturday suggested in this case it would be good to wait for the final mix as what we heard live was still a work in process done so they could get the video footage they needed. I for one will be interested in what it sounds like when it comes out.
Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
I think the last three U2 records are better than the first 3. War is amazing but No Line, Innocence and Experience I find miles better than Boy and October