1. Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
    Yeah so what, they've had loads of hits from the 80s to 00s not many bands can claim that or had number 1 albums of original material in 4 different decades.
    We fans don't need new hit and prefer honest quality music but they are in desperate need of making hit...
  2. Originally posted by Alvin:[..]
    We fans don't need new hit and prefer honest quality music but they are in desperate need of making hit...
    Not every fan has the same idea of what makes honest quality. I do agree in general that I don’t care anymore about them having a hit but why would this new song be considered as trying to be a hit. There’s very few songs in the charts that have proper and obvious instrument playing like on this song, or have the depth of lyrics of this song. Unfortunately it seems the band can’t win now no matter what they release there’s always someone complaining. There’s no way we can say stylistically they’ve adopted the same approach from NLOTH up til now but they’ve had very little success or praise since then, from breathe and moment of surrender to California and the troubles to lights of home and love is bigger with songs like invisible, ordinary love and now this new song in between albums, I think it’s all pretty different and all various levels of good/great.
  3. To be fair, people will still complain about a new release regardless of the band or artist. I think that's pretty normal.
  4. Originally posted by KieranU2:To be fair, people will still complain about a new release regardless of the band or artist. I think that's pretty normal.
    That’s true, especially nowadays with social media everyone’s opinion is heard and the more popular the artist probably bizarrely the more negative comments as well at times because they can’t go unnoticed.
  5. Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
    That’s true, especially nowadays with social media everyone’s opinion is heard and the more popular the artist probably bizarrely the more negative comments as well at times because they can’t go unnoticed.
    It's probably always been like that though, but you're right that social media has given opinion a spotlight I suppose. I don't think the way people perceive something has changed.
  6. Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
    Not every fan has the same idea of what makes honest quality. I do agree in general that I don’t care anymore about them having a hit but why would this new song be considered as trying to be a hit. There’s very few songs in the charts that have proper and obvious instrument playing like on this song, or have the depth of lyrics of this song. Unfortunately it seems the band can’t win now no matter what they release there’s always someone complaining. There’s no way we can say stylistically they’ve adopted the same approach from NLOTH up til now but they’ve had very little success or praise since then, from breathe and moment of surrender to California and the troubles to lights of home and love is bigger with songs like invisible, ordinary love and now this new song in between albums, I think it’s all pretty different and all various levels of good/great.
    I agree. The post Pop U2 is different, and again the post NLOTH U2 also different. I'm glad they're still around, putting out decent music and especially still touring (I hope).
    This song is fine. I find the chorus very catchy and it will probably fit well over the end credits of the movie. To me it's a similar league as Ahimsa, which I've revisited recently and enjoy, even though I was thrown off by it when it came out. I also think it's as good or better than several SOE songs.
    As for songs geared towards the Oscars, I think this song is superior to Hands (forgettable except for the great middle 8) and Ordinary Love (too forced). Since similarities with Windows in the Sky have been mentioned, I also think it's superior it.
    Yes it's no Mofo or The Fly but I'm totally okay with this new song.
  7. Originally posted by Alvin:[..]
    all awards (grammys/mtv) are now corrupted with cheesy and uninspired hiphop/rnb/pop so i don't really care about any... so it wouldn't be even any honor to recieve these...


    Sure you could argue the Grammy's have always been rubbish. How many did HTDAAB win? 8, 9???
  8. Originally posted by KieranU2:[..]
    It's probably always been like that though, but you're right that social media has given opinion a spotlight I suppose. I don't think the way people perceive something has changed.
    I think there are people that are easily influenced though, I mean it’s pretty much scientifically proved how we can influenced and social media I’m sure will have quite a strong impact on people. I think people with more of a sure mind of what they like and dislike won’t be influenced as easily but you’ll definitely get people reading a certain amount of negative comments or indeed positive and they’ll feel more inclined to dislike or like a song based on that, especially if it’s one of they middle ground songs to start with where they aren’t sure if they like or dislike it yet. You see it everywhere in life, football teams an opinion will start going around and suddenly everyone’s spouting the same opinion, ask someone to explain that opinion and you’ll often find a struggle to come up with a valid response.
  9. Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
    I think there are people that are easily influenced though, I mean it’s pretty much scientifically proved how we can influenced and social media I’m sure will have quite a strong impact on people. I think people with more of a sure mind of what they like and dislike won’t be influenced as easily but you’ll definitely get people reading a certain amount of negative comments or indeed positive and they’ll feel more inclined to dislike or like a song based on that, especially if it’s one of they middle ground songs to start with where they aren’t sure if they like or dislike it yet. You see it everywhere in life, football teams an opinion will start going around and suddenly everyone’s spouting the same opinion, ask someone to explain that opinion and you’ll often find a struggle to come up with a valid response.
    I’ve learned on social media the loudest voices tend to be the negative ones. Yesterday I was seeing a bunch of comments about how this isn’t a U2 song, it’s a Bono solo song. Looked at it later in the day and realized it was the same person over and over. They wanted their opinion to be heard.

    I don’t think it will ever be my favourite song. But i don’t get the hate for it. It’s pretty much what I was expecting from a soundtrack side project type thing. Gives me something new to listen to. I am amazed at the four in the morning lyric, which tied it back to The Little Things. Almost a continuation of that story. That was kind of a neat touch. Adds something to it when you know U2’s songs and aren’t just getting exposed in the theatre.

    And I’m happy to see U2 stretching out and trying to cultivate new listeners. At their age they could have just done a few more albums and a few tours. The bills are paid, the kids are out of the house. But U2 X-Radio goes after the satellite FM owners, the Martin Garrix track went for the soccer fans, this goes for a younger audience, they did 55 remixes of Love is Bigger and held Pride events to celebrate the song to go after the LGBT audience. They keep pushing into new corners to see who they can reach. Tells me they haven’t given up yet…
  10. We shouldn’t really be surprised that this is complete rubbish. Let’s look at what preceded it: ‘Ahimsa’ (or Asthma as I prefer to call it), that dreadful remix EP they released to coincide w/ playing in Mumbai, ‘Bang A Gong’ (U2 have never been & never will be a good covers band), ‘We The People’ (or whatever it was called). All of them are dire. I didn’t think things could get worse than Ahimsa. But clearly they can. This is one of the worst things I’ve heard from this band.
  11. Originally posted by Reach1985:We shouldn’t really be surprised that this is complete rubbish. Let’s look at what preceded it: ‘Ahimsa’ (or Asthma as I prefer to call it), that dreadful remix EP they released to coincide w/ playing in Mumbai, ‘Bang A Gong’ (U2 have never been & never will be a good covers band), ‘We The People’ (or whatever it was called). All of them are dire. I didn’t think things could get worse than Ahimsa. But clearly they can. This is one of the worst things I’ve heard from this band.
    Yeah but then there's small glances of hope like the Sean Penn song which wasn't half bad... I'm confused.
  12. 1. I said "now" and I meant last cca 10 years (in 90'-00's there was a lot of good artists awarded)

    2. HTDAAB is my least favourite album so it would just prove my point lol