Originally posted by blink:I think there are about 5 tracks I like… many skip songs unfortunately for me. Let’s see how the record will grow.
Originally posted by JDLM:[..]
I loved *Easter Lily* and keep listening to it; if the new album had 2 tracks from *Ash* and 3 or 4 from *CDL*, it would be a top 5 album for me.
I would have put the tracks from these three—*Carnival*, *Ash*, and *Lily*—together as a trilogy on a single LP, but I’m happy with what they’re giving us.

Originally posted by BonoIsTheMessiah:As a lifelong U2 fan, I think there are two kinds of U2 albums: (1) those that are masterpieces, and (2) those that are just very good.
If you think this album sucks, or only like a few of the songs, I don't think you are much of a fan of the band. This is the best thing they have done since the All That/Atomic Bomb era and perhaps since Achtung Baby. Every song is fantastic. At the very least it is just a very good album like most of the last 15.
Originally posted by TheUglyOne:[..]
I have been a fan since 1982, after borrowing the first two LPs from a cousin.
From ATYCLB onwards, there are at least 4 songs on every album that I don’t enjoy listening to, including tracks like Stuck in a Moment, Sometimes You Can't Make It, The Miracle, You're the Best Thing. Moment of Surrender, Glorify. Songs that other fans like very much.
I have tickets for 6 European shows and maybe I will visit the US next year too. Their concerts are magical and take me back to my youth and bring back memories.
For me there are three kinds of U2 albums: those that are masterpieces, those that are just good and those that are average.
I consider myself a fan, but does that mean I’m not allowed to be critical?