1. Levi Evans
  2. A Council Of U2Start Members
  3. JulienLossless
  4. U2Freak999 would certainly cut the mustard
  5. I vote for Seneca!
  6. Josh Homme would be ok with me for the rock album
  7. Originally posted by pleasegone:[..]
    So if all the vocals sound like Auto Tune...uh err uh Love Is All We Have Left, you would be ok with it? I seriously doubt they would, but that's what I'm complaining about. Severe use of a trend that has not been done by one or two artists, but billions of them seems more like trend following rather than trend setting, which U2 used to do. I don't see any Auto Tune use as being creative, I just see it as doing what you think a young audience would want. Following this trend seems awful to me. I know I'm showing my age, but I am not receptive to any voice alteration with certain exceptions. I like it on Zoo Station. I like a lot, but not all, of what Prince used to do with his "Camille" sped up voice. I never liked Vocoders or Talk Boxes in the 70's and 80's. Bon Jovi's Living On A Prayer uses it a tiny bit, and it does not ruin the song. I can tune in to a local R&B station where it is used to an extreme on nearly every single song, where the vocals for almost every single song sound about the same. I know each generation seems to be more into doing what everyone else is doing, but having a uniform vocal requirement is horror to me. I love being able to quickly say..."That's Aretha Franklin...that's James Brown, that's Phil Collins." I will never say that is Auto Tune preset 4.55. That's not me. Now if U2 uses it as pitch correction to where I can't even tell, I can live with that, but I'd rather hear Bono croaking his way through Beautiful Day live than have him sound perfect all the time. I want real, live vocals, and I want studio songs with a real authentic vocal take.


    it's okay for the youth - and really it is a bit of a 'punk' 'street' thing to do as it has gone from helping mediocre transient pop acts just singing in tune to enabling anybody with a song and a message to be able to record, release and perform music

    why should we look down upon a singer needing help with creating a tuneful (or trendy) vocal?

    is it any different from edge using multiple effects to achieve his vision?

    but regarding the use of it by our own band - yes, it's just like embarrassing dad dancing
  8. Regarding autotune on SoE - it's not like they used it for a cheerful pop song! It's perfect for what they were trying to achieve with Love Is All We Have Left, which Bono described at one point as "Frank Sinatra singing on the moon"
  9. Originally posted by TheRealEdge:[..]


    it's okay for the youth - and really it is a bit of a 'punk' 'street' thing to do as it has gone from helping mediocre transient pop acts just singing in tune to enabling anybody with a song and a message to be able to record, release and perform music

    why should we look down upon a singer needing help with creating a tuneful (or trendy) vocal?

    is it any different from edge using multiple effects to achieve his vision?

    but regarding the use of it by our own band - yes, it's just like embarrassing dad dancing
    If it were a song here or there in popular music, even though I would still hate it, I'd understand. Nearly every single R&B or hip hop single uses it. And most don't use it to correct bad singing voices. They flood the song with it to the point where you can hardly tell the difference between any of the singers. And since it is not just a few acts doing their own thing, it makes it look like a requirement if you make any kind of an R&B song. It has not really caught on with rock, which is sort of a blessing, but I don't just come from a rock background. I started out with Queen, J Geils Band, Stevie Wonder, then next came Michael Jackson, then Prince, The Police, and eventually got around to U2 in 1987. Having my favorite band use this in any context hurt my soul. If it were some groundbreaking new technology, then at least I'd have some understanding...but it was something that BILLIONS AND BILLIONS AND BILLIONS of other acts had alredy done, making it look more like trend following (old band trying to copy what the young people are doing).