Originally posted by Remy:[..]
Andy Barlow please.
Originally posted by Remy:[..]
Andy Barlow please.
Originally posted by mickoafc:Josh Homme would be ok with me for the rock album
Originally posted by pleasegone:[..]
So if all the vocals sound like Auto Tune...uh err uh Love Is All We Have Left, you would be ok with it? I seriously doubt they would, but that's what I'm complaining about. Severe use of a trend that has not been done by one or two artists, but billions of them seems more like trend following rather than trend setting, which U2 used to do. I don't see any Auto Tune use as being creative, I just see it as doing what you think a young audience would want. Following this trend seems awful to me. I know I'm showing my age, but I am not receptive to any voice alteration with certain exceptions. I like it on Zoo Station. I like a lot, but not all, of what Prince used to do with his "Camille" sped up voice. I never liked Vocoders or Talk Boxes in the 70's and 80's. Bon Jovi's Living On A Prayer uses it a tiny bit, and it does not ruin the song. I can tune in to a local R&B station where it is used to an extreme on nearly every single song, where the vocals for almost every single song sound about the same. I know each generation seems to be more into doing what everyone else is doing, but having a uniform vocal requirement is horror to me. I love being able to quickly say..."That's Aretha Franklin...that's James Brown, that's Phil Collins." I will never say that is Auto Tune preset 4.55. That's not me. Now if U2 uses it as pitch correction to where I can't even tell, I can live with that, but I'd rather hear Bono croaking his way through Beautiful Day live than have him sound perfect all the time. I want real, live vocals, and I want studio songs with a real authentic vocal take.
Originally posted by TheRealEdge:[..]
it's okay for the youth - and really it is a bit of a 'punk' 'street' thing to do as it has gone from helping mediocre transient pop acts just singing in tune to enabling anybody with a song and a message to be able to record, release and perform music
why should we look down upon a singer needing help with creating a tuneful (or trendy) vocal?
is it any different from edge using multiple effects to achieve his vision?
but regarding the use of it by our own band - yes, it's just like embarrassing dad dancing