1. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:Sounds horrible. Am I the only one who thinks u2 songs come off poorly when performed acoustically, they need that Edge delay and various other effects he uses.

    The only song I would exclude from this would be the version of STAY ZOO Tv but even that had Bono plugged in electrically with some reverb or slight delay ringing thru.
    In ZooTV Stay, main guitar is played by Edge, not Bono.
  2. That's debatable. Bono and his chords started the song and provided the root of it
  3. Suggest just accept it for what it was - a couple of mates having a singalong in a pub with friends after a couple of pints. Focus on the fun they seem to be having, rather on the quality of the performance.
  4. Umm I know that ... edge was playing an acoustic with an electric pickup in it , Bono was playing an Electric Guitar.
  5. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:Sounds horrible. Am I the only one who thinks u2 songs come off poorly when performed acoustically, they need that Edge delay and various other effects he uses.

    The only song I would exclude from this would be the version of STAY ZOO Tv but even that had Bono plugged in electrically with some reverb or slight delay ringing thru.


    Couldn’t disagree more. Stripped down versions of stay and one rank among my favorites. I’d also say that staring at the sun and a man and a woman are much better acoustically than their full band counterparts
  6. Stay Live in Sydney is the benchmark of U2 acoustic tracks.
  7. Okay let me quantify my statement, Stay wasn't acoustic in ZOO Tv, it was full band with only the Edge playing a traditional *acoustic* guitar ( Gibson Humming Bird - I think ) with a *pickup* to amplify the sound to a stadium sized audience.

    Bono was playing his semi hallow 'it feels good' Gibson ES175 Ebony *electric* guitar.

    Adam playing electric bass.

    Larry in a stripped down drum kit ( standing from memory )

    I'm talking only Acoustic guitars (inc acoustic Bass) and Larry on a single snare only, similar to when they played Ordinary Love on The Late show with Jimmy Fallon ( I think it was ) which didn't sound to bad I must admit.

    But there are very few examples were a song is played totally stripped down that has those chord filling effects pedals beefing The Edge's sound out that hits the mark IMHO.
  8. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:Okay let me quantify my statement, Stay wasn't acoustic in ZOO Tv, it was full band with only the Edge playing a traditional *acoustic* guitar ( Gibson Humming Bird - I think ) with a *pickup* to amplify the sound to a stadium sized audience.

    Bono was playing his semi hallow 'it feels good' Gibson ES175 Ebony *electric* guitar.

    Adam playing electric bass.

    Larry in a stripped down drum kit ( standing from memory )

    I'm talking only Acoustic guitars (inc acoustic Bass) and Larry on a single snare only, similar to when they played Ordinary Love on The Late show with Jimmy Fallon ( I think it was ) which didn't sound to bad I must admit.

    But there are very few examples were a song is played totally stripped down that has those chord filling effects pedals beefing The Edge's sound out that hits the mark IMHO.
    It was an electric version, in fact when they first played it on tour it was on the main stage.
  9. Yes, they played it on the main stage in Nijmegem, e. g. - in Dublin three weeks later I feared that they might have dropped it, but then they did it on the b-stage, which was great as all of you have can hear.
  10. Dublin 93 Stay was excellent as well.