1. Originally posted by dstankie:Huh?
    I'm not saying who's the best band--I'm just trying to find a band with a stable lineup that went longer than 20 years releasing GREAT, SIGNIFICANT music. And so far, I don't think anyone has named one.


    One more time then: Rush, R.E.M., Queen, Radiohead, Depeche Mode, INXS, Genesis, Pink Floyd. Their fans would disagree with putting U2 on the list by the way (October, R&H, Zooropa - what’s great or significant about those?).
  2. What's great about Rush? Couldn't tell you one song they ever done.Queen are probably the most overrated band of all time and I've only ever met one Depeche Mode fan 😆
  3. Originally posted by kezman:What's great about Rush? Couldn't tell you one song they ever done.Queen are probably the most overrated band of all time and I've only ever met one Depeche Mode fan 😆
    You realise that your impressions are totally subjective, right? Objectively all those bands, including U2, are in the same league with regard to achievements. Fans will argue but again all those bands have their fans.
  4. One more time then: Rush, R.E.M., Queen, Radiohead, Depeche Mode, INXS, Genesis, Pink Floyd. Their fans would disagree with putting U2 on the list by the way (October, R&H, Zooropa - what’s great or significant about those?).


    I'll take your word for it on Rush.

    REM, like U2, had a great run before making mediocre, mixed-bag stuff.

    Queen had about 20 years before Freddy died, so not longer.

    Depeche Mode. I mean, I guess so? But has anyone considered the later albums to be essential or significant in any way?

    INXS had less than 20 years before Michael died.

    Genesis had lineup changes all the time, with the most famous guys leaving long before 20 years.

    Pink Floyd was Barrett's band then Waters'/Gilmore's band. Both those runs together don't equal 20 years.

    NO band has released only top-notch albums for 20 years, including U2. October, R&H, and Zooropa were all solid albums that were important in the band's development and were part of a 20 year run of great strength.

    (Complete tangent: Zooropa IS a great album. R&H is woefully underrated. You tell me how many other band release an off-album with THREE new songs that made the band's all-time canon?)

    I won't post again on this because it's not on topic in this thread. I was simply musing that 20 years seems to be about the max for a band to remain artistically sharp.

    I WASN'T trying to rank bands or argue only U2 was great.

    "Solo" artists (who often work with lots of different musicians) have gone beyond this "limit", which makes sense. It just seems against the odds for a group of artists working together to be able to keep finding magic together after a while and not simply repeat themselves or do things that are less artistically successful.
  5. To support what your saying, here’s three bands I like or used to like, who have existed for around 30 years and had some great albums, but who fail to make the grade:
    - Counting Crows: great debut and follow up, but line up changes and inconsistent quality disqualifies them.
    - Garbage: steady line up and early stuff was great, but later albums disappointed.
    - Placebo: great early stuff but they churn through drummers and quality has declined over time.

    I can’t even nominate my current favourite band - The Airborne Toxic Event. I’ve loved every album but it’s only 17 years since their debut and they’ve had 2 of their 5 members change in that period.

    Sustained stability and high quality output over two decades IS elusive, even for U2
  6. Originally posted by Bonu:[..]


    One more time then: Rush, R.E.M., Queen, Radiohead, Depeche Mode, INXS, Genesis, Pink Floyd. Their fans would disagree with putting U2 on the list by the way (October, R&H, Zooropa - what’s great or significant about those?).
    even their fans would disagree with you
  7. Originally posted by dstankie:[..]


    I'll take your word for it on Rush.

    REM, like U2, had a great run before making mediocre, mixed-bag stuff.

    Queen had about 20 years before Freddy died, so not longer.

    Depeche Mode. I mean, I guess so? But has anyone considered the later albums to be essential or significant in any way?

    INXS had less than 20 years before Michael died.

    Genesis had lineup changes all the time, with the most famous guys leaving long before 20 years.

    Pink Floyd was Barrett's band then Waters'/Gilmore's band. Both those runs together don't equal 20 years.

    NO band has released only top-notch albums for 20 years, including U2. October, R&H, and Zooropa were all solid albums that were important in the band's development and were part of a 20 year run of great strength.

    (Complete tangent: Zooropa IS a great album. R&H is woefully underrated. You tell me how many other band release an off-album with THREE new songs that made the band's all-time canon?)

    I won't post again on this because it's not on topic in this thread. I was simply musing that 20 years seems to be about the max for a band to remain artistically sharp.

    I WASN'T trying to rank bands or argue only U2 was great.

    "Solo" artists (who often work with lots of different musicians) have gone beyond this "limit", which makes sense. It just seems against the odds for a group of artists working together to be able to keep finding magic together after a while and not simply repeat themselves or do things that are less artistically successful.
    Yes, it is very difficult, near impossible for a rock band to have a stable lineup for 20 years or more and only put out great and artistically significant or at least commercially successful albums. And that includes U2. They are special but not THAT special.

    Bands do not start and continue to exist naturally, especially these days. Natural form of artistic expression is via a solo career. Only big money and marketing rock/pop machines can change this perspective. Jazz musicians can attest to that. How many painting or sculpture bands can you name?

    Also, I only included Genesis and Pink Floyd because they did what they did with CORE members only. They didn’t add anyone else from outside those bands when Peter Gabriel, Steve Hackett or Roger Waters left. They continued with remaining core members only and both bands continued to be very successful.
  8. … they would also add that Boy wasn't one of the greatest and most significant debut albums in rock history. It was surely very significant for U2 history though. It’s all a matter of perspective.
  9. Judging by the comments by some long time members here and from myself being a member for well over 8 years it would really appear as though this is ‘last chance saloon’ for the band with this forthcoming record. I know I for one is really looking forward to it. The mash up of styles ( didn’t work on SOE ) should work and allow them to push the envelope a little more. Comments from the band members have also suggested that they are speaking in a way that takes most of the pressure off them in regards to capturing a hit single and chart topping album. I think ( I hope ) we might be in for a nice surprise with a cohesive album that pushes the bands sonic horizon. That said you can’t please everyone there will always be members of this forum that have widely different tastes when it comes to this bands best music. Wouldn’t it be boring however if we all like the same shit!?
  10. Judging by the comments by some long time members here and from myself being a member for well over 8 years and observing patience running low it would really appear as though this is ‘last chance saloon’ for the band with this forthcoming record. I know I for one is really looking forward to it. The mash up of styles ( didn’t work on SOE ) should work and allow them to push the envelope a little more. Comments from the band members have also suggested that they are speaking in a way that takes most of the pressure off them in regards to capturing a hit single and chart topping album. I think ( I hope ) we might be in for a nice surprise with a cohesive album that pushes the bands sonic horizon. That said you can’t please everyone there will always be members of this forum that have widely different tastes when it comes to this bands best music. Wouldn’t it be boring however if we all like the same shit!?
  11. 49 years ago today in Larry’s kitchen.