1. Originally posted by j1167198:Let me get this straight. Ash and Easter are outtakes EPs that they don't consider good enough for the album.

    In order to release these two EPs they must have already decided some time back what the track listing for the LP was. Or at least decided what the LP wasn't.

    https://www.irishtimes.com/culture/music/2026/04/03/u2s-new-ep-easter-lily-review-an-endearingly-honest-questing-record-thats-almost-cool/

    Maybe this also means they won't have time during the new tour to play any older songs -- a set list of 24 new songs would be something!
    I think the goal here is to keep 'conceptually similar' songs close in a unified manner. Try and forget for the time being about 'albums, release dates, marketing etc.' These are just internet drops. There also was an urgency to the ASH drop because it was so topical.

    It is not they aren't good enough, just different.


  2. I think it's more they won't fit on the album - it sounds thematically they are heading somewhere very specific with the album, and there won't be room for some of this more political or spiritual leaning songs. These are songs they really wanted to put out and not hold until yet another album down the road. I don't think "not good enough" was part of the criteria. The band seem very proud of this material.
  3. Originally posted by j1167198:Let me get this straight. Ash and Easter are outtakes EPs that they don't consider good enough for the album.

    In order to release these two EPs they must have already decided some time back what the track listing for the LP was. Or at least decided what the LP wasn't.

    https://www.irishtimes.com/culture/music/2026/04/03/u2s-new-ep-easter-lily-review-an-endearingly-honest-questing-record-thats-almost-cool/

    Maybe this also means they won't have time during the new tour to play any older songs -- a set list of 24 new songs would be something!

    I wouldn't say they weren't good enough however they haven't released an album proper in 9 years due to many factors that we all know about, they probably had a huge amount of songs/ideas written in that time frame so probably needed to get some of them out that wouldn't fit the theme of the album, or that they didn't have to tie into a tour or big promo campaign ,
  4. Isn’t Bono quoted as saying we’ve got 25 songs ready to go? So these last 2 EP’s of 12 songs narrows down the choice to the 10/11 they feel fits the narrative of the type of music,and or theme,they want to take on the road as travelling salesmen for the next 2 years.
  5. I think that Bono said that after Days of Ash EP was released, so they should have about 25 songs minus 6 on the Easter Lilly. Plenty to choose from for an album. They still might be writing some more.
  6. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]


    I think it's more they won't fit on the album - it sounds thematically they are heading somewhere very specific with the album, and there won't be room for some of this more political or spiritual leaning songs. These are songs they really wanted to put out and not hold until yet another album down the road. I don't think "not good enough" was part of the criteria. The band seem very proud of this material.
    yea, it’s their best work in decades
  7. Originally posted by Bonu:I think that Bono said that after Days of Ash EP was released, so they should have about 25 songs minus 6 on the Easter Lilly. Plenty to choose from for an album. They still might be writing some more.
    Bono says with every release they have 50+ songs to chose from. I take those remarks with a shipload of salt...
  8. So, I was working yesterday doing my daily writings, nothing special... and I got my Spotify on random, and "One Life At A Time" starts playing...

    And, as I was writing about one of the many wars happening right now... the song hit as the exact motivation I needed to keep writing and remain motivated with my work and remembering there is good and decent people out there in many places who believe in the best of humanity, and who like U2, try the best they can and are willing to keep listening with their hearts and growing to be able to build Peace

    And I, finally, I liked it!

    Turns out things just take time and the right timing....

    To all fans of "One Life At A Time", and who understand what it stands for, thank you!

    And big thanks to U2 for being a lighthouse in this tempest!
  9. The band is putting together a collection of songs that are equivalent to Street of Dreams. Which it isn’t a terrible song but when I compare Tears of things to Dreams, Dreams feels very empty lyrically by comparison. Days of Ash minus the first track is incredibly strong.
  10. Originally posted by Monopoly:The band is putting together a collection of songs that are equivalent to Street of Dreams. Which it isn’t a terrible song but when I compare Tears of things to Dreams, Dreams feels very empty lyrically by comparison. Days of Ash minus the first track is incredibly strong.
    "Tears of Things" is a lyrical masterpiece. Also, it is an outlier, as it can knock out any song from any album, Passengers onwards (1995-present). I would even dare to say it could knock out 2-3 songs off Zooropa.

    However, I really don't think, at all, that the songs in the New Album are going to be like "Street of Dreams".

    Remember U2 tries to make every song very different from each other. Even in "Songs of Experience" (please excuse the terrible "American Soul" and "Get Out of Your Own Way") every song stands as sonically different from each other.

    Landlady
    Red Flag Day
    Love Is All We Have Left
    13 (There Is A Light)
    Love Is Bigger
    Little Things
    Summer of Love
    The Blackout

    As you can see, they are all very different from each other.

    So, having said this, can U2 still make an album that's better than HTDAAB, NLOTH, SOI, and SOE? Yes.

    Is "Street of Dreams" better than anything on those 4 albums? Yes.

    So, if "Street of Dreams" is the worst song off the new album, and the rest of the songs are on the same level as "Tears of Things" and Easter Lily, then it will be a great album.

    Let's just wait, June 11/12 is just 2 weeks away. The album just 4 months away.
  11. Originally posted by Monopoly:The band is putting together a collection of songs that are equivalent to Street of Dreams. Which it isn’t a terrible song but when I compare Tears of things to Dreams, Dreams feels very empty lyrically by comparison. Days of Ash minus the first track is incredibly strong.
    bro, literally achtung baby has ONE