1. I thought at the time New York could have been a single but I think they'd issued enought from ATYCLB at that point. My go to version is the Nasty Mix because it's got such a driving beat to it, plus the switching of output from right to left speaker entertains me.
  2. Too bad that song never had a life after the touring cycle.
  3. I cannot praise this enough. Where do you even start with this; there’s layers upon layers here.
  4. Coul you please copypaste it?

    I can't see it ☹️
  5. The OP of the post says:

    This song always appears to be people's favorite from the new music drop. I keep going back to it, trying to get it to click. But I just don't think the song is very good. It's a pretty average chord progression and melody, doesn't really do anything exciting, production is average, etc. What about the song is so appealing to so many of you?


    There's over 120 responses so it's too much to copy and paste here but my favorite response is:


    The lyrics. And the power of the simplicity of the song to highlight and accentuate the power of the lyrics. It’s stripped down, raw, vulnerable. Even this lapsed Christian feels the gut punch of “Cause when people go around talking to God It always ends in tears.”

    The reckoning of how people have distorted Christianity since the beginning of the institution to justify some of the most horrendous inhumane things, and what that means to be a Christian now, to be David when the Goliath we’re facing feels unbeatable. To not have hearts of stone, but be open to the tears and brokenness of it all. It’s an incredibly powerful song.

  6. Originally posted by Sydney_MIke:I thought at the time New York could have been a single but I think they'd issued enought from ATYCLB at that point. My go to version is the Nasty Mix because it's got such a driving beat to it, plus the switching of output from right to left speaker entertains me.
    I will have to listen to this mix as NY is one of my favs especially the reworked version live after 9/11. Talk about capturing lightning in a bottle at that time!
  7. Don't forget these ones as well. 4 official remixes and approx. 3 official live versions. Irving Plaza, Farmclub.com and Boston Elevation. According to u2songs.com

    "New York" (Carnegie's Deli Remix) - U2
    "New York" (Superman Kicks Ativan Remix)
  8. Still masterful.
  9. This is a very paired back Greatest Show on Earth. The slow layered build to the big crescendo drummed in by Larry.