I’m excited for what is to come from the band; the album & world tour especially. The shadow album, the EPs and now the first new studio album in almost 9 years - what gifts from the band.
I guess I had dreams of a mind blowing single, that showcased the live power of the band and being able to rock out. To just go wow, okay, they actually delivered a heavy rocker with an important message. So I’m disappointed that after such a long time between new albums and all the rubbish posted about Larry… I wanted a sonic statement - Larry’s back & everything you know is wrong!
I need to stop believing Bono and just appreciate whatever the band release on it’s own merit. One song that I continue to blast in my car is Happiness. I just can’t get enough of Larry’s thumping drums and that awesome Edge solo. I love the EPs, I’m sure the single will grow on me, intrigued to hear Silencio and no doubt the album will be huge.
I have liked every album since Pop less than the preceding one. I am highly unlikely to ever listen to SOI or SOE from start to finish ever again.
At this stage, I assume I’m not going to be the biggest fan of any new material they put out (I don’t love the EPs) but I always remain hopeful that the band will surprise me.
My view on SOD hasn’t really changed since hearing the initial clips. Having said that, 1) it’s extremely catchy and 2) I wouldn’t pre-judge the album based on it (hearing it has me no way excited for the new album, though).
If this gets a new / younger audience for them, that’s great news for the band but roll on the album and let’s see what they’ve got up their sleeves.
About the whole "unhinged/unreasonable guitars" expectations, the way I see it:
U2: talks about making a grapefruit bread, people get excited; mentions other possible flavours, such as blueberry; says they're starting fresh with all 4 members in the kitchen, hints they're going for banana bread; lets the smell of banana bread leak out to people; finally takes banana bread out of the oven and serves it to people.
People not getting the taste of grapefruit on the banana bread:
As for SOD, I get that the whole lead single comparison is kinda inevitable, and of course there'll be lovers, haters, and in-betweens (and to each their own), but in the end, I feel that one of the song's major assets is that it doesn't try to be more than it is.
It's not aiming to be "the new vertigo/beautiful day" (let alone the next "one"), nor is it an ode to the past or an original breakthrough to the future; it's a simple and undeniably catchy song, with its merits and its limitations. And I bet this very simplicity is acting as a double-edged sword, which undermines expectations while it gains hearts.
Seems to me like they're playing it safe and aiming at a broader reach through an earworm radio tune, at least for starters, and if so, they're spot on.
Too safe a move from the band? If you wanted a bold statement, for sure! If you're just in for the ride (with its highs and lows), then you might be in for a good time. Personally, I'll wait for the full album, cause the promise of a "carnival of songs, hope, and serious fun" could end up being a much-needed joyful decompression in these polarized times.
Last but not least, I'd rate the song a decent 6,5-7/10; loved the chorus and the melody, liked the back and forth between bono and edge on the verses (guess most didn't care for it), and really enjoyed the main riff and overall percussion and bass lines. Simple words on a predictable but nice idea, good vibes, and impressively catchy AF. With that said, I do feel the energy drop between choruses and verses, I agree the bridge is limited, and from start to finish it really doesn't lead up sonically to many different places, it's a one-trick-dog, but it seems like a good enough trick...