To be clear I wasn’t comparing this song to any of those songs and I don’t feel it stands side by side in direct comparison. The Fly and Numb are both all time favourites and I think Pop is a masterpiece.
But I was pointing out we’ve heard the “worst song they’ve ever done” a number of times over the years. Including the albums that the original poster brought up.
Yes, totally. I'm old enough to remember when some fans felt that the Joshua Tree was the band selling out.
Though as I always say, there's a difference between "I don't like this music" and "this music is bad."

