1. Originally posted by Bonu:I can’t get over how close they were to recording one of the best albums in their career and surely best since Achtung Baby and destroyed it in the last minute by their own doing. They should have made a contemplative, beautiful album in veins of TUF from start to finish and they had songs for that. If only they replaced the infamous trio of songs in the middle of the album (Crazy, Boots and SUC) with Winter, early version of Every Breaking Wave and some other song they had surely stashed for Songs of Ascent, or even NLOTH 2, it would have been such a fantastic album. But oh well, they wanted number 1 hits… in result they had neither the hits nor the cohesive beautiful album that they had on their hands. Nor Songs of Ascent that they were presenting at the time as a reason why NLOTH looked as it did with some of more contemplative songs left out. Their decisions were just bizarre and counterproductive. I hope they deliver that dream album that they were supposed to release in 2009 in a super deluxe version of NLOTH one day…

    PS if they were afraid that such a low-key album would have been difficult to tour, they could have released a nice little live EP to commemorate start of 360 where they could have offloaded all those songs they wanted to push (Crazy, Boots, SUC, live Crazy remix etc.).
    Yes so true,
  2. Originally posted by Bonu:I can’t get over how close they were to recording one of the best albums in their career and surely best since Achtung Baby and destroyed it in the last minute by their own doing. They should have made a contemplative, beautiful album in veins of TUF from start to finish and they had songs for that. If only they replaced the infamous trio of songs in the middle of the album (Crazy, Boots and SUC) with Winter, early version of Every Breaking Wave and some other song they had surely stashed for Songs of Ascent, or even NLOTH 2, it would have been such a fantastic album. But oh well, they wanted number 1 hits… in result they had neither the hits nor the cohesive beautiful album that they had on their hands. Nor Songs of Ascent that they were presenting at the time as a reason why NLOTH looked as it did with some of more contemplative songs left out. Their decisions were just bizarre and counterproductive. I hope they deliver that dream album that they were supposed to release in 2009 in a super deluxe version of NLOTH one day…

    PS if they were afraid that such a low-key album would have been difficult to tour, they could have released a nice little live EP to commemorate start of 360 where they could have offloaded all those songs they wanted to push (Crazy, Boots, SUC, live Crazy remix etc.).
    Yes so true,
  3. This is still one of my favorite albums because it was the first tour I saw them on it was so fresh in so many ways. Yet it does seem to have been their phase where they were super creative AND scared to really go for their first intuitions. I.e., original Mercy being botched in so many subsequent versions, Winter and Soon being left of the album. (I do like Boots even tho I don’t want to like it.)

    I do accept that if THEY weren’t ready to show their full colors, and not releasing SOA either, it wasn’t the right time. It seems SOI, SOE, Stories of Surrender and SOS, have resulted in a much freer band that will show so many colors from now on. Them accepting to write and finish so many aspects of the EPs this year at the last moments I think testifies to that.

    Maybe all this relative hesitancy of the last decades, that brought great music and live shows if you ask me, was needed for a breakthrough. And will allow them to care less and more at the same time.

    I hope my theory is right haha
  4. Despite its flaws, still an inspiring album. Fez and Unknown Caller are probably my favourites along with the title track.
  5. I love Moment of Surrender, Magnificent and Fez the most. Unknown Caller not so much with all those oh ohs. I think it lost much of its charm and is my least favourite of the tracks that I would still keep on the album regardless.
  6. It’s the lyrics of unknown caller I can’t go. The music for that song I love. I think that sums up quite a bit of the album for me actually.
  7. I used to really like this album but I play it less and less and even though the tour was great - this album hasn't aged well at all

    If they would've dropped the 'singles' then I have to say tbh, it would be quite a dull album - except for Breathe really
  8. I agree, Here is my alternative NLOTH album, I'm calling it Linear.
    Side A
    1. Fez-Being Born
    2. No Line on the Horizon 1
    3. Breathe
    4. Magnificent
    5. White as Snow
    6.Unknown Caller
    Side B
    1. Soon
    2. NLOTH 2
    3. Crazy Tonight
    4. Winter
    5. Moment Of Surrender
  9. In an alternative history, here is the tracklist for the album Songs of Innocence and Experience.

    Side A
    1. Blackout
    2. Lucifers Hands
    3. 13
    4. Red Flag Day
    5. Iris
    6. Crystal Ballroom
    7. Summer Of Love
    Side B
    1. Lights Of Home
    2. Cedarwood Road
    3. The Troubles
    4. Raised by Wolves
    5. The Little Things....
    6. Every Breaking Wave (piano version)
  10. Originally posted by newnala123:I agree, Here is my alternative NLOTH album, I'm calling it Linear.
    Side A
    1. Fez-Being Born
    2. No Line on the Horizon 1
    3. Breathe
    4. Magnificent
    5. White as Snow
    6.Unknown Caller
    Side B
    1. Soon
    2. NLOTH 2
    3. Crazy Tonight
    4. Winter
    5. Moment Of Surrender
    I’d definitely replace Crazy with Cedars of Lebanon in that alternative album of yours. Perhaps also add Every Breaking Wave (SoS version) cause this song really belongs to that era.
  11. Underrated album, if you ask me.
    The film ‘Linear’ is still great to watch.