Originally posted by Bonu:I can’t get over how close they were to recording one of the best albums in their career and surely best since Achtung Baby and destroyed it in the last minute by their own doing. They should have made a contemplative, beautiful album in veins of TUF from start to finish and they had songs for that. If only they replaced the infamous trio of songs in the middle of the album (Crazy, Boots and SUC) with Winter, early version of Every Breaking Wave and some other song they had surely stashed for Songs of Ascent, or even NLOTH 2, it would have been such a fantastic album. But oh well, they wanted number 1 hits… in result they had neither the hits nor the cohesive beautiful album that they had on their hands. Nor Songs of Ascent that they were presenting at the time as a reason why NLOTH looked as it did with some of more contemplative songs left out. Their decisions were just bizarre and counterproductive. I hope they deliver that dream album that they were supposed to release in 2009 in a super deluxe version of NLOTH one day…
PS if they were afraid that such a low-key album would have been difficult to tour, they could have released a nice little live EP to commemorate start of 360 where they could have offloaded all those songs they wanted to push (Crazy, Boots, SUC, live Crazy remix etc.).