1. Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    That being said, according to social media and Youtube comments fans (both casual and proper) are really digging this crappy version of SBS. So maybe it's just us in our small bubble who don't like it.


    I was going to mention this last night. It's funny how different platforms often have different views. There's nothing but positivity regarding this SBS on Facebook, but there's nothing but negativity here on U2Start.
  2. Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    I get what you're saying and you definitely have a strong point, BUT: releasing this poor version when they're openly talking about a new album of reworked/rearranged older songs is not the smartest thing to do imho, because it brings any possible excitement down.

    That being said, according to social media and Youtube comments fans (both casual and proper) are really digging this crappy version of SBS. So maybe it's just us in our small bubble who don't like it.

    The guy is 60 odd hasn't been touring for a while the fact he can still sing reasonably well is a good thing.
  3. I’m quite surprised that the performance is getting good comments elsewhere. Maybe helps the meaning behind it with it being posted on the 50th anniversary of Bloody Sunday and the fact it’s one of their big songs in general but it really is a version that does nothing for me, won’t be one I revisit anyway having gave it a few listens now to confirm my initial thoughts. Still open minded about other reworkings though, this is just one song and not amongst my favourite U2 songs either.
  4. I don't mind the recording - it's intimate and informal. It's not a studio recording, and it's not a live version either. The voice is there. Bono is just trying a different tack on a song he's sung tons of times already. Bono + Edge only worked well for SOL in 92-93 anyway, as far as I'm concerned. Still quite excited about the next few projects. Let's hope we won't have to wait n more years until the next album / reworking of old song, whatever comes first.

  5. Just posting this for posterity.
  6. It's great that Bono doesn't sing as usual SBS, I liked it, after all Bono's voice should be the innovation of this album, what can you expect from an acoustic guitar? nothing. will be faithful to the original song.
  7. That album they released in 2012?
  8. No the one they released in 2014 although I’ve just read the full quote again and realise what you’re saying. I’m not expecting a new album until late 2023 at the earliest anyway now. I think they’ll get the reworks album out this year though. Completely different project to working on brand new material.
  9. Originally posted by SJKamal:[..]


    I was going to mention this last night. It's funny how different platforms often have different views. There's nothing but positivity regarding this SBS on Facebook, but there's nothing but negativity here on U2Start.
    That is because U2Starter's have a disease called the '1000 club'. When you have listened to a track played live 1000 times one's perception is skewed!
  10. I still hope one day Bono does "swing" album... with or without u2
    think about

    2 Shots,
    Dancing Shoes,
    I've Got You Under My Skin
    That's Life
    Velvet Dress (Jools version)
    Let The Good Times Roll
    ...
    5-6 more tracks like that and that would be awesome and some new territory album.
  11. I think Bono needs to release a box set of his identifiable solo tracks. The ones in which he sings lead vocals.