1. The project reeks of "contractual obligation" and "album quota". The only member actively enthused about it is Bono because it's all about him and he can talk about it. And talk about it. And talk about it. Not sure I want to surrender to any of it.
  2. Originally posted by cmaly:The project reeks of "contractual obligation" and "album quota". The only member actively enthused about it is Bono because it's all about him and he can talk about it. And talk about it. And talk about it. Not sure I want to surrender to any of it.
    It's literally been produced by Edge and he sings lead vocals on a bunch of the songs.
  3. Originally posted by cmaly:The project reeks of "contractual obligation" and "album quota". The only member actively enthused about it is Bono because it's all about him and he can talk about it. And talk about it. And talk about it. Not sure I want to surrender to any of it.
    It’s not a contractual obligation from what I understand. The label would have likely preferred a straight up best hits kind of thing. And Bono’s been talking about how nice it is to work without those obligations and to do what they want. These type of re-imagined collections tend to be poor sellers for other artists. It’s the last thing a record label would likely push for…

    And this whole project appears to be Edge’s baby. He did a lot of the early development on songs, it’s him on lead vocals on a number of places, he engineered most of it and was the overall producer on the album. And he’s doing the liner notes and much of the promo for the album itself so far. (Letters to fans, quotes in press releases etc.)
  4. @u2wanderer Do you know anything about the album cover?


  5. It was really meant to be four very separate discs, with four different covers. I notice on iTunes it appears the individual tracks may get the same treatment with four covers throughout.

    They may have done this one as animated so people see it as four different images instead of one. Pride is on the Edge’s disc, so will be interesting to see if they change it when the full album is released.
  6. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]


    It was really meant to be four very separate discs, with four different covers. I notice on iTunes it appears the individual tracks may get the same treatment with four covers throughout.

    They may have done this one as animated so people see it as four different images instead of one. Pride is on the Edge’s disc, so will be interesting to see if they change it when the full album is released.
    Fair... that makes sense. I wondered if the cover itself will change and feature multiple images?
  7. But then why choose 3 photos from the Pop era and one from TUF era.
  8. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]


    It was really meant to be four very separate discs, with four different covers. I notice on iTunes it appears the individual tracks may get the same treatment with four covers throughout.

    They may have done this one as animated so people see it as four different images instead of one. Pride is on the Edge’s disc, so will be interesting to see if they change it when the full album is released.
    4 different versions with different eras of the band would have been sooo much better. Collectors would snap that up too.
  9. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
    It’s not a contractual obligation from what I understand. The label would have likely preferred a straight up best hits kind of thing. And Bono’s been talking about how nice it is to work without those obligations and to do what they want. These type of re-imagined collections tend to be poor sellers for other artists. It’s the last thing a record label would likely push for…

    And this whole project appears to be Edge’s baby. He did a lot of the early development on songs, it’s him on lead vocals on a number of places, he engineered most of it and was the overall producer on the album. And he’s doing the liner notes and much of the promo for the album itself so far. (Letters to fans, quotes in press releases etc.)
    Do you know by any chance how actively Larry and Adam were involved? From the snippets I've heard it sounds like a lot of Edge overdubs + Bono singing, but no real rhythm section.
  10. Only two simple questions. Does anyone know why there is a 16 and 20 title of SOS 40 songs? What I don't understand at all is why have the titles of beautiful day, red mining town, UNTIL THE END OF THE WORLD and WITH OR WITHOUT YOU disappeared?
  11. Originally posted by felix2:Only two simple questions. Does anyone know why there is a 16 and 20 title of SOS 40 songs? What I don't understand at all is why have the titles of beautiful day, red mining town, UNTIL THE END OF THE WORLD and WITH OR WITHOUT YOU disappeared?
    To make more money. With the colour vinyl they’re calling 4 songs ‘bonus songs’ compared with the regular versions, just trying to give people another reason to buy the limited versions.