Originally posted by vertigone160:I think the studio version is arguably the weakest version of the song. Bono’s vocal sounds awfully dragged out at times.
Potentially true but when you rarely visit the studio album because the song is phenomenal live then you can really step back and appreciate it.
I’m fact I’d go as far as to say that the recorded version and live versions are almost separate entities.
Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
Potentially true but when you rarely visit the studio album because the song is phenomenal live then you can really step back and appreciate it.
I’m fact I’d go as far as to say that the recorded version and live versions are almost separate entities.
I would agree.
In fact, when I was a budding fan - I’d heard the studio version of Bad a hundred times (courtesy of the greatest hits 80-90 album) before I heard the live version (rattle and hum was the first version I’d heard/seen) and when I did, it completely threw me off. In truth, I actually didn’t like the live version at first !
To me, the album version is very intimate, almost romantic or something - whereas the live version is powerful, cathartic, etc.
It’s like one is meant for your ears only, while the other is meant to be a shared experience.
Main difference I think between album and live version is that the album version is a jam that differs in timing, whereas live it has the clicktrack + sequencer
I think I struggle to separate the studio from live versions in terms of being able to appreciate each for what they are. I can’t help but compare and I much prefer the live version but I guess if they’d never played the song live I would still enjoy the album version as a very good song just not a great one to me. I only listen to the album version when playing TUF album in full.
Originally posted by melon51:Main difference I think between album and live version is that the album version is a jam that differs in timing, whereas live it has the clicktrack + sequencer
Studio version beats everything. Adam is so un-Adam, Larry is wild - and 4.30-4.40 is pure magic, this is the master piece of Edges Less-is-more-playing. And the only song Bono sings better than this is in the first verse of ISHFWILF from TJT. This was really U2 at their best.