1. Also, my favorite U2 vocal of all time is and will always be the original Red Hill Mining Town. I get why they didn’t play it live until 2017…it’s a bitch to sing. But damn, it’s absolutely perfect.
  2. Originally posted by Hoosier2012:Also, my favorite U2 vocal of all time is and will always be the original Red Hill Mining Town. I get why they didn’t play it live until 2017…it’s a bitch to sing. But damn, it’s absolutely perfect.
    It’s definitely wild.

    It’s so bizarre to think that it was the intended first single off of Joshua Tree. Apart from Bono’s amazing vocal, I would say it’s a far cry from “hit single” material, but maybe that’s just my opinion.
  3. Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    Yeah, we sometimes get blinded by the live versions and forget how great are these songs on the records. What about Still Haven't Found? That vocal is absolutely unreal, so much intensity from literally the first verse. In fact the vocals on the opening trio of JT are hard to believe.


    Have to say how lucky I was as an 18yr old in '87, as a newly qualified driver, to be ambling all over Ireland on holiday with a mate ahead of the Croke Park shows (we went to both) & hearing that song all over Irish radio. Windows down, radio up. Such a tune and such memories. Truly the happiest of days...
  4. Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]
    It’s definitely wild.

    It’s so bizarre to think that it was the intended first single off of Joshua Tree. Apart from Bono’s amazing vocal, I would say it’s a far cry from “hit single” material, but maybe that’s just my opinion.
    It might still be my favorite studio track from that album, just because of the absolute balls of that vocal. It’s close between that, ISHFWILF, and Trip Through Your Wires.
  5. Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
    Streets was the main one I was hinting at. As transcendent as it is Live, the version on record is just stupendous. I still struggle with believing Bono stood in a booth and delivered that vocal. The rhythms of Larry and Adam stir the tummy. Masterpiece.


    Can't agree more. And how about the ending that significantly differs from the live versions

    "Oh, and I see love
    See our love turn to rust
    We're beaten and blown by the wind
    Blown by the wind
    Oh, when I go there
    I go there with you
    It's all I can do"

    Just perfect.
  6. Originally posted by DaddyGJ:[..]


    Have to say how lucky I was as an 18yr old in '87, as a newly qualified driver, to be ambling all over Ireland on holiday with a mate ahead of the Croke Park shows (we went to both) & hearing that song all over Irish radio. Windows down, radio up. Such a tune and such memories. Truly the happiest of days...
    Wow, sounds like an incredible Summer trip around Eire, in the best year to do so. Amazing 🙂
  7. Originally posted by DaddyGJ:[..]


    Have to say how lucky I was as an 18yr old in '87, as a newly qualified driver, to be ambling all over Ireland on holiday with a mate ahead of the Croke Park shows (we went to both) & hearing that song all over Irish radio. Windows down, radio up. Such a tune and such memories. Truly the happiest of days...
    I love stories like that. Shows you how powerful of a connection to memories music can be.
  8. Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]

    100% - there's a reason it's still my favourite song of all time, recorded version or otherwise 🙂

    Hell, even the video still puts a huge smile on my face

    [..]

    100%

    I honestly think there's an argument to be made for Still Haven't Found being (objectively - if art can be that 😛) their all-time greatest song/recording. The arrangement/recording is sublime, the lyrics are timeless and universal, it's incredibly catchy and easy to sing along to, it kinda has everything.
    You definitely have three big points there. We might be so tired of it because the band never made it justice live (and still kept insisting on playing it tour after tour), but the song itself as recorded in 1986 is a complete work of art. I'd also argue it's possibly the song that the most random people in any given city of the world are bound to hum when asked if they know something from U2.
  9. Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    I understand you, and many times I've felt the same. My solution was to start listening only to random songs from random bootlegs. Sometimes I won't listen to any live U2 for weeks. And then when I do for whatever reason (usually having to check/upload something for U2start, or just stumbling upon a surprising fact/snippet while randomly browsing U2gigs) it always sounds fresh and exciting again.
    Hahaha this just happened again.


    I was listening to 1983-11-30 - Tokyo trying to elucidate the so-called broadcast that might exist of the show as mentioned by @Eljimferr in this post.


    So I came across a really crazy version of I Will Follow that features:

    -the longest duration of any IWF version... ever? Clocking in at 5 minutes and 3 seconds.

    -a false start: Bono stops Edge and Larry during the buildup of the intro and he shouts "This song's for our manager Paul McGuinness" and then they restart it with even more energy.

    -a middle eight that's almost 2 minute long, with Bono improvising and.. Well, singing "These streets are fire, fire for love... These streets are the unforgettable fire... Unforgettable fire, the unforgettable fire, unforgettable fireee". CRAZY SHIT.
  10. Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    Hahaha this just happened again.


    I was listening to 1983-11-30 - Tokyo trying to elucidate the so-called broadcast that might exist of the show as mentioned by @Eljimferr in this post.


    So I came across a really crazy version of I Will Follow that features:

    -the longest duration of any IWF version... ever? Clocking in at 5 minutes and 3 seconds.

    -a false start: Bono stops Edge and Larry during the buildup of the intro and he shouts "This song's for our manager Paul McGuinness" and then they restart it with even more energy.

    -a middle eight that's almost 2 minute long, with Bono improvising and.. Well, singing "These streets are fire, fire for love... These streets are the unforgettable fire... Unforgettable fire, the unforgettable fire, unforgettable fireee". CRAZY SHIT.
    Whoa what the fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu-

    Isn't there something similar with...I want to say Iris or something? Like Bono was singing some lyrics from Iris decades before it came out? Could be totally wrong...

    I gotta check that IWF out haha.
  11. Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]
    Whoa what the fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu-

    Isn't there something similar with...I want to say Iris or something? Like Bono was singing some lyrics from Iris decades before it came out? Could be totally wrong...

    I gotta check that IWF out haha.
    Here you are my man