Originally posted by BloodyValentine:You read a thread like this on Reddit where people mouth off about how much they hate U2 and how they're overrated, with generic music, generic guitar playing, that Edge is a one-trick pony who over-relies on delay and Bono is overly self-regarding with bland, preachy lyrics and then you realize, oh yeah, I get that now.
I'm a fan of U2 but one side of me agrees with the worst, least generous criticism of the band and can completely see all of them in this musical turd they just dumped.
https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicRock/comments/16jqogz/what_is_a_band_you_hate_that_everyone_else_seems/
It's all true.
Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
So you’re here because…?
Originally posted by BloodyValentine:[..]
"One"

Originally posted by TheRealEdge:just been listening to this again (or variants of this) - this is what the band needs again: an exciting genre to jam with and see what works
fuck off with the over-polished safe 'rock'
[YouTube Video]
Originally posted by guykirk9:I don’t think that is Edges fault that the band have opted to go the route they have gone since 2011.
I think regression is a bit harsh, I would argue he has gotten older (as the band has) and the music hasn’t warranted the same sound.
Originally posted by BloodyValentine:[..]
"One"
Originally posted by bonoschild:[image]
[..]
I agree with this, but we also have to think about where they were 30 years ago headspace-wise. The musical landscape, relationships being strained, touring JT forever and ultimately wanting to chop it down... then add in thoughts about relevance, having individual families, age and illness. I'm sure it all affects them creatively. Atomic City is a decent enough song, and I'm eager to hear the studio version. But it just sounds safe, rehashed and borrowed. This pic kinda sums up my view at the moment on it
Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
I know that I personally love hanging around message boards of things I enjoyed 32 years ago (hope the heavy sarcasm is picked up) why not.. ya know.. invest all this time and energy into something you DO enjoy?
Originally posted by BloodyValentine:[..]
But then I'd miss out on all the invaluable free psychoanalysis that I get from armchair therapists like yourself.
Originally posted by miryclay:[..]
The name Atomic City is almost as bizarre as Frank Zappas children's names.