1. I wonder how many of the reworked versions will be better than the originals. Undoubtably some will be. Whereas some will be absolute stinkers.
  2. So any of you lot excited about this new album of reworked songs? I'll be honest I'm struggling to be interested, really looking forward to the book though
  3. Originally posted by kezman:So any of you lot excited about this new album of reworked songs? I'll be honest I'm struggling to be interested, really looking forward to the book though
    To be honest, the news that most of the tracks will be the same usual warhorses has lowered my expectations a lot.
  4. What I don't understand about it is how it has been revealed that the old/rearranged songs will sound different than the original songs. How can you explain the time difference from 2019 to 2022, that these songs will sound really different if they are played live? At the latest for the promo for 40 songs and in the Sphere in Las Vegas 2023. We're talking about almost 4 years.
  5. Originally posted by beerok:[..]
    To be honest, the news that most of the tracks will be the same usual warhorses has lowered my expectations a lot.
    Same. When I was expecting forgotten gems like Luminous Times, Surrender, and Another Time, Another Place mixed in with some warhorses, I was very, very excited. Now that I know more than a quarter of the songs are from the last decade and most of the rest are warhorses, I’m a bit disappointed.

    Still, I am intrigued to hear all the different versions of songs, and forty newish songs is nothing to sneeze at.
  6. It depends on how much they re-work them!
  7. Tracklist of the 1CD- Version? 😉

    Confirmed Titles of Chapters in Surrender

    “Out of Control” – U2 (From Boy)
    “11 O’Clock Tick Tock” – U2 (Non-Album Single)
    “Two Hearts Beat as One” – U2 (From War)
    “Bad” – U2 (From The Unforgettable Fire)
    “Where the Streets Have No Name” – U2 (From The Joshua Tree)
    “With or Without You” – U2 (From The Joshua Tree)
    “One” – U2 (From Achtung Baby)
    “Beautiful Day” – U2 (From All That You Can’t Leave Behind)
    “Vertigo” – U2 (From How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb)
    “City of Blinding Lights” – U2 (From How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb)
    “Ordinary Love” – U2 (Non-Album Single)
    “Iris (Hold Me Close)” – U2 (From Songs of Innocence)
    “Song for Someone” – U2 (From Songs of Innocence)
    “The Showman (Much More Better)” – U2 (From Songs of Experience)

    Originally posted by u2wanderer1:I’ll point out we were told about “Songs of Surrender” before the title of the book was announced or known. The book title was announced almost two months after we were told about the album title.
  8. Originally posted by beerok:[..]
    To be honest, the news that most of the tracks will be the same usual warhorses has lowered my expectations a lot.
    Long post to follow:

    I was becoming a bit intrigued by Songs of Surrender until I saw all of the Songs of Innocence and Songs of Experience tracks. Not sure why any track off the last 2 albums has to be reworked. Especially for Songs of Innocence as we got the busker / acoustic versions of the those Innocence tunes on the deluxe version of the album. I know this has been stated here before....

    Bottom Line:
    I love Bono's storytelling and the animations. I am looking forward to reading the book. I am not enchanted with the this bloated project of 40 reworked songs...

    We also found out that the Edge and Adam were recording U2 songs in stripped down arrangements during Lock Down. I wonder if this project grew and became a forced companion to Bono's 40 chapter book. Or did Bono intend for the band to re-record 40 songs at the very beginning of his book project?
  9. I think they started off as 2 different projects. Bono was writing his book, whilst Edge got a "bee in his bonnet" and started to rework some of U2s songs. I assume somewhere down the line they then decided to merge the reworked songs with Bono's book. Ultimately creating one big project.
  10. Originally posted by LostSailor:[..]
    Long post to follow:

    I was becoming a bit intrigued by Songs of Surrender until I saw all of the Songs of Innocence and Songs of Experience tracks. Not sure why any track off the last 2 albums has to be reworked. Especially for Songs of Innocence as we got the busker / acoustic versions of the those Innocence tunes on the deluxe version of the album. I know this has been stated here before....

    Bottom Line:
    I love Bono's storytelling and the animations. I am looking forward to reading the book. I am not enchanted with the this bloated project of 40 reworked songs...

    We also found out that the Edge and Adam were recording U2 songs in stripped down arrangements during Lock Down. I wonder if this project grew and became a forced companion to Bono's 40 chapter book. Or did Bono intend for the band to re-record 40 songs at the very beginning of his book project?
    I think they were probably always tied.

    We know Bono’s book was supposed to be out last Fall, and was delayed a year for rewrites. (He confirmed this in New York during the talk given. The band read the book and made suggestions, and he decided he could improve on what was there. Adam in particular felt he was written as a caricature.)

    Adam also started talking about working on the reworked tracks at the same time that they would have been making the decision to postpone the book. At one point he even mentioned a possible Fall 2021 release. Which would have matched the original plans for the book.

    So I think they were intended for the book tie-in as far back as early 2021 anyway.
  11. U2wanderer1,

    I am assuming you have heard Songs of Surrender multiple times already. Do you have a favourite track?
  12. Originally posted by SJKamal:I think they started off as 2 different projects. Bono was writing his book, whilst Edge got a "bee in his bonnet" and started to rework some of U2s songs. I assume somewhere down the line they then decided to merge the reworked songs with Bono's book. Ultimately creating one big project.
    Imagine how cool it would've been had all 4 members wrote autobiographies and they released them together as a super boxed set?