1. That would have been Epic!!!
  2. Originally posted by kezman:So any of you lot excited about this new album of reworked songs? I'll be honest I'm struggling to be interested, really looking forward to the book though


    I am. But they’ve done a few of my favourite songs and I like remixes / reworks in general. And I am looking forward to some of the more experimental stuff. I don’t think we are going to get experimental stuff on a main album again, so if this allows Edge to go off in new directions, I’ll happily take a listen. And it’s nice the rest of the band aren’t completely out on the sidelines while Bono is doing the book stuff. I’m probably more excited about the recreated songs than the book itself.
  3. Originally posted by kezman:[..]
    Imagine how cool it would've been had all 4 members wrote autobiographies and they released them together as a super boxed set?


    Out of all the band members I would be most interested in reading Claytons. Followed by Edges.

  4. Originally posted by kezman:[..]
    Imagine how cool it would've been had all 4 members wrote autobiographies and they released them together as a super boxed set?


    That sounds like KISS to me
  5. Some things to consider with reworking.

    1)key changes and instrumentation changes are possible. See EBW
    2)playing live over time allow the songs to go in unexpected directions
    3)producers can be very influential to a final track. A 'defeated' idea of the past could be explored or re-born
    4)band infighting could be consequential. See Mercy
  6. 5) technological advances could allow for ideas of the past to be re-examined. See early Live UF tour struggles or How Soon is Now by The Smiths.
  7. I love early and raw UF. The lack of technology then made UF so visceral live.
  8. Both Marr and Edge struggled to replicate studio arrangements in a live setting. Marr figured it out after the band broke up.
  9. Originally posted by SJKamal:I wonder how many of the reworked versions will be better than the originals. Undoubtably some will be. Whereas some will be absolute stinkers.


    None of them will be better than the originals other than perhaps something from the last two albums.
  10. I wouldn't be so certain about that.
  11. For me it’s less a question of something being better or worse than the originals - I like seeing alternate interpretations. I was initially intrigued by the idea of songs that always struck me as “great ideas not fully realized” - Another Time, Another Place, most of Pop, etc - and while I think we might still get that with Two Hearts, it’s less something I anticipate at this point.

    Also, if Shine Like Stars and/or Hear Me Coming aren’t included, aren’t we like morally obligated as U2 fans to riot?