Originally posted by MoFoNYR15:[..]
I mean I’ve been a fan of u2 since I was 3. And I agree, SOI was the last good music they made. That’s my opinion. I loathe SOE and SOS isn’t sounding like anything worthwhile. Throw in this “Vegas residency “, which is a term I never wanted to hear alongside u2 and it’s been a dark time for me personally. But I’ll always love this band , no matter what. Why can’t a fan be critical and still be a fan? I never understood this. Am I not a fan because I think SOE is trash? Should I only post here when I enjoy something the band does?
I think it’s just hard to believe that a fan can dislike everything about a certain album. I would guess a very high percentage of u2 fans like at least 1 song from every album. To dislike an album as a whole piece of work is different but to say not one song on the album is worth having just seems unbelievable. I like more than half of my least favourite u2 album just as a comparison but we are all different just didn’t realise we were that different as fans. I guess I’m also unique in a way with being very happy with what they’ve done in the last decade or so and glad that SOE exists despite some criticism but also keen for them to go in a very different direction next time round. There just seems to be a real lack of balance at the moment amongst fans, people that love whatever the band do and those that can’t stand just about everything. I’m probably closer to the first group but can still be critical of certain aspects. Certainly don’t see songs like American soul and showman worthy of a u2 album. But also could pick a few from SOE that would be amongst my top 20 or 30 from the band.
Originally posted by Unodostres123:[..]
I think it’s just hard to believe that a fan can dislike everything about a certain album. I would guess a very high percentage of u2 fans like at least 1 song from every album. To dislike an album as a whole piece of work is different but to say not one song on the album is worth having just seems unbelievable. I like more than half of my least favourite u2 album just as a comparison but we are all different just didn’t realise we were that different as fans. I guess I’m also unique in a way with being very happy with what they’ve done in the last decade or so and glad that SOE exists despite some criticism but also keen for them to go in a very different direction next time round. There just seems to be a real lack of balance at the moment amongst fans, people that love whatever the band do and those that can’t stand just about everything. I’m probably closer to the first group but can still be critical of certain aspects. Certainly don’t see songs like American soul and showman worthy of a u2 album. But also could pick a few from SOE that would be amongst my top 20 or 30 from the band.
Yes.... The Little Things That Give You Away is the best thing U2 has done in the last 13 years. I am very grateful to U2 for giving me such a masterpiece in so late in their career.
I don’t think we have any other choice but to enjoy this if you can bring yourself to that point. There was just something about hearing Bono tell the stories and singing these songs on his book tour.
There was an acknowledgement within me of accepting that there really isn’t long left and every opportunity we get to see and hear them should be considered a blessing. Do I feel the need to spend hundreds of pounds on multiple editions of this release? Absolutely not. A CD for the shelf to go with the rest at most. Will I think it’s a great volume of work? Likely not. Am I grateful that it exists? Yes.
Take what joy you can, while you still can. If you can’t then it still doesn’t discredit all that has come before that did bring you joy. Stick with that.
Originally posted by germcevoy:I don’t think we have any other choice but to enjoy this if you can bring yourself to that point. There was just something about hearing Bono tell the stories and singing these songs on his book tour.
There was an acknowledgement within me of accepting that there really isn’t long left and every opportunity we get to see and hear them should be considered a blessing. Do I feel the need to spend hundreds of pounds on multiple editions of this release? Absolutely not. A CD for the shelf to go with the rest at most. Will I think it’s a great volume of work? Likely not. Am I grateful that it exists? Yes.
Take what joy you can, while you still can. If you can’t then it still doesn’t discredit all that has come before that did bring you joy. Stick with that.