1. Originally posted by dstankie:[..]


    Exactly. His vocal performances are way better on the book tour than anything I've heard from SOS so far.

    And this: U2 has done their most magical work when others (mainly Eno and Lanois) helped them transcend themselves. U2 as U2 alone has actually always had fairly constrained limits. Think Unforgettable Fire, Joshus Tree, Achtung Baby. Each album was the sound of a band becoming something other/more than they had been or were previously capable of. The music was not just "good," it was astonishing. It was strange at first, then became essential to my life, as if it was something I'd always needed but didn't know until we had it. I know I'm far from alone in that experience, which is what made it all so remarkable: a popular "mainstream" band was making astonishing and necessary music.

    When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?


    First thing that comes to mind is California, if I’m completely honest. The weird intro, and that chorus that sounded like a ray of sunshine hitting your face with that crazy synth wall (which they regrettably never tried to recreate live).

    But if I sit and think about it, it’s gotta be those few select songs on NLOTH that truly sound like nothing else this band has done. I’m talking:

    Winter
    White as Snow
    Fez - Being Born
    Cedars of Lebanon
    Moment of Surrender
    Soon
  2. Originally posted by bridonohue:[..]

    This(!!)

    Sometimes
    The air is so anxious
    All my thoughts are so reckless
    And all my innocence has died
    Sometimes
    I wake at four in the morning
    Where all the darkness is swarming
    And it covers me in fear
    Sometimes
    Sometimes
    Sometimes
    Sometimes
    I'm full of anger and grieving
    So far away from believing
    That any song will reappear
    Sometimes
    The end is not coming
    It's not coming
    The end is here
    Sometimes


  3. FEZ / Being Born and some other songs on the Song of... albums (Sleep Like a Baby, Book of your Heart...)
  4. Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]


    First thing that comes to mind is California, if I’m completely honest. The weird intro, and that chorus that sounded like a ray of sunshine hitting your face with that crazy synth wall (which they regrettably never tried to recreate live).

    But if I sit and think about it, it’s gotta be those few select songs on NLOTH that truly sound like nothing else this band has done. I’m talking:

    Winter
    White as Snow
    Fez - Being Born
    Cedars of Lebanon
    Moment of Surrender
    Soon
    Your post inspired to go back and listen to my modified NLOTH playlist. I must say this stuff has aged well. Beautiful music and very nice production and arrangements. Too bad they ruined it with 2-3 godawful tracks in search of that elusive 'hit' as well as a bad running order.
    From an artistic point of view, I think this era might have produced the best music they have done post 2000.
  5. Originally posted by beerok:[..]
    Your post inspired to go back and listen to my modified NLOTH playlist. I must say this stuff has aged well. Beautiful music and very nice production and arrangements. Too bad they ruined it with 2-3 godawful tracks in search of that elusive 'hit' as well as a bad running order.
    From an artistic point of view, I think this era might have produced the best music they have done post 2000.
    I would agree. I feel like anyone who’s been around here long enough has seen me type it too many times, but yeah - NLOTH is amazing when it’s not U2 trying to recreate Vertigo or ATYCLB. It’s obvious (and they’ve actually confirmed as much) that halfway through recording a very experimental record, they said “but what about the hits we need to play on tour?” And we lost the other half of that experimental album.

    Some of the material of that era is just out of this world. I just wish they would’ve been willing to go all the way with it.

    At least we have those few songs that we do.
  6. Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]
    I would agree. I feel like anyone who’s been around here long enough has seen me type it too many times, but yeah - NLOTH is amazing when it’s not U2 trying to recreate Vertigo or ATYCLB. It’s obvious (and they’ve actually confirmed as much) that halfway through recording a very experimental record, they said “but what about the hits we need to play on tour?” And we lost the other half of that experimental album.

    Some of the material of that era is just out of this world. I just wish they would’ve been willing to go all the way with it.

    At least we have those few songs that we do.
    I actually like the mix of music on No Line. And also the running order. I view it like a cassette. Side one ends with Crazy Tonight. That said I don’t really like Breathe’s placing and Fez/Being Born could be an opener.
  7. That any sun will reappear ?

    AMEN... I had tears in my eyes for the first 10-20x repeats... so heavy emotionally if you are helpless or downed by life... yet so uplifting! Best U2 thing in last 10-15 years!
  8. I have to answer my own question. I agree that NLOTH is almost a great album. And I agree that some of SOE is astonishing in that I didn't think they had it in them to sound that urgent and move me that much anymore.

    Like all of us, I will always be rooting/hoping for one last release that takes my breath away start to finish.
  9. Originally posted by dstankie:I have to answer my own question. I agree that NLOTH is almost a great album. And I agree that some of SOE is astonishing in that I didn't think they had it in them to sound that urgent and move me that much anymore.

    Like all of us, I will always be rooting/hoping for one last release that takes my breath away start to finish.
    I think Every Breaking Wave and Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way are prime examples of U2's best work.
  10. Every Breaking wave and The Little things would be prime examples that they can still create some great songs in their latter part of their career IMO.
  11. Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
    Every Breaking wave and The Little things would be prime examples that they can still create some great songs in their latter part of their career IMO.
    Nice fix