Originally posted by dstankie:[..]
Exactly. His vocal performances are way better on the book tour than anything I've heard from SOS so far.
And this: U2 has done their most magical work when others (mainly Eno and Lanois) helped them transcend themselves. U2 as U2 alone has actually always had fairly constrained limits. Think Unforgettable Fire, Joshus Tree, Achtung Baby. Each album was the sound of a band becoming something other/more than they had been or were previously capable of. The music was not just "good," it was astonishing. It was strange at first, then became essential to my life, as if it was something I'd always needed but didn't know until we had it. I know I'm far from alone in that experience, which is what made it all so remarkable: a popular "mainstream" band was making astonishing and necessary music.
When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?
First thing that comes to mind is California, if I’m completely honest. The weird intro, and that chorus that sounded like a ray of sunshine hitting your face with that crazy synth wall (which they regrettably never tried to recreate live).
But if I sit and think about it, it’s gotta be those few select songs on NLOTH that truly sound like nothing else this band has done. I’m talking:
Winter
White as Snow
Fez - Being Born
Cedars of Lebanon
Moment of Surrender
Soon