There are some very good new takes. There are also some very bad ones. Bottom line is that I prefer U2 to sounds like a rock band. And this isn't that.
1. With Or Without You- It's good...not as good as the performance from The Late Show
2. Stay- Leonard Cohen vibes?
3. Sunday Bloody Sunday- We've pretty much heard this for a while now...new lyrics are fitting
4. Lights of Home- For some reason reminds me of what they did with the acoustic Staring At The Sun
5. Cedarwood Road- Sounds too much like the acoustic from the deluxe SOI
6. I Will Follow- Understood the assignment
7. Two Hearts- Really like this!
8. Miracle Drug- Lovely new interpretation.
9. Little Things- It's good....I can see this performed in a pub somewhere.
10 40- 40 really isn't a fave of mine but I like this version. War is 40 years old and this song sounds as calming as ever.
after a first listen... it's a good album, didn't need to have 40 songs, if it was only 20 songs it will be more great...
my top 20
bad
whos gonna ride your wild horses
red hill mining town
all i want is you
pride (in the name of love)
vertigo
with or without you
sunday bloody sunday
i will follow
the little things that give you away
lights of home
11 o'clock tick tock
until the end of the world
ordinary love
every breaking wave
invisible
sometimes you can't make it on your own
song for someone
cedarwood road
if god will send his angels
I've managed to squeeze one full listen in so far. In general, I'm actually quite impressed with this project. It's nothing to shout from the rooftops about, but the sheer scale of it - 40 songs - gives it a slightly mad ambition that I'm on board with. Some of the reimaginings are phenomenal. Some are pretty boring. Some are baffling but still pretty interesting in their own mad way (yes, I'm talking about GOOYOW - it's so weird). I like that they went with 40 songs, because it gave them the licence to reach for the deeper cuts and not stick to the warhorses. The most famous songs are usually the most boring in the collection and many of the deep cuts really stand out.
My favorites right now:
- 11 O'Clock Tick Tock - surprised with this, because the shorter clips didn't impress me, but in full it really shines. Weird ending though.
- Walk On - I did find the pre-album live performances cringey, but I warmed up to the new lyrics, and this song was really calling for a reimagining because of what happened with Aung San Suu Kyi.
- Red Hill Mining Town - I hated the 2017 version, but this one really works.
- Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own - very moving.
- Dirty Day - 10/10 version, a huge improvement over what they did to the song on the E+I tour and arguably better than the original (which has weird volume level issues that have always annoyed me)
- The Miracle (Of Joey Ramone) - I've had the new chorus in my head for a few days now
- I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For - I like the country/Johnny Cash mood of this one, I also like the Eno/Lanois cameo
- Electrical Storm - again, the clips weren't impressive, but the full version is really good and has a nice dynamic
- The Fly - bold and weird in a good way
- Desire - bold and weird in a good way. I love the dark groove and the distortion.
- Stay - love Bono's low register and I appreciate that they found a new angle for a song that has been performed acoustically in the past
- 40 - this should have been the single. None of the songs they chose to release earlier are among the strongest (although Beautiful Day is close).