Originally posted by mattfromcanada:Man, so apparently Window In The Skies isn't a well liked song either? I rather enjoyed it. I'm also seeing a lot of shots at October too. To put my fandom in context, I became a fan in 1996. And the order in which I learned about U2 and listened to the albums was TUF, JT, AB, Boy, October, War, Zooropa. And I didn't spin JT and AB a lot in the early days of my fandom. The big ones were Boy, October, War, like a LOT, and I'm sure that October got more time that War. So all three of those hold a place in my heart, and really if you listen to October in it's context is it really such a bad album? How would you have performed if your 6 months of lyrics had been stolen? It's very tough / unfair almost stacking albums up against each other and ranking them because each is a snapshot on it's own. Like can you listen to October and go "Achtung Baby is way better!" as if to slam the 1981 U2 for not whipping out an Acrobat or So Cruel? Where was I going with this? Oh yeah, listened to it about another 10 times this weekend and I really like it!